Rate a Tiger's year - 3. Brett Deledio?

[one-eyed]

Next up is Lids.

For the third year in succession, Lids played all 22 games in the season to take his career tally to 128 matches. This makes him now the third most experienced player on our list behind Newman and Tuck. As a half-back, Lids reached 30 or more disposals on four occasions with his best effort against Hawthorn in round 8 where he had 35. All but two matches were above 20 possessions (lowest 18 vs Melb R19). Lids finished the season runners-up in the B&F and was selected in the initial 40-man All-Australian squad.

Career so far....
           Games     Disposals   Marks    Tackles    G.B (total)
2005:     22            15.3         3.9       1.7         14.10
2006:     21            18.8         6.5       1.7           5.12
2007:     19            18.4         5.4       1.9         21.10
2008:     22            24.5         7.0       2.2         28.10
2009:     22            24.2         5.4       3.5         20.15
2010:     22            25.3         5.3       2.5           2.4

http://finalsiren.com/PlayerStats.asp?PlayerID=1529&SeasonID=ALL

How did we all rate Lids' year?

[TigerTimeII]

even though he didnt win the jd medal this was lids breakout yr, his best thus far, lids has come of age and will be our goddard

[Heart of Darkness]

Wonderful year from lids and by far his most consistent as he had 2 "bad" games all season i thought. One part of lids that often is forgotten as one eyed mentioned is his durability and ability to play 22 games a season which is incredibly vital. Gave him an 8. Know many on here dont agree but i think for him and the team to move to the top echelon status in this league we need his class and match winning ability around the ball. Would love to see lids kicking a 15-20+ goals a year

[Willy]

this bloke is all class.
love him.

[wayne]

His last quarter against Adelaide showed exactly what he is capable of.

Look forward to seeing more of it.

[Tigermonk]

his season was nothing exciting a 5

[Heart of Darkness]

his season was nothing exciting a 5

Love to see what a 9-10 then is...35 possies 4 goals a game u expecting from lids. All of that playing as a backmen not to much to expect is it??

[Go Richo 12]

his season was nothing exciting a 5

Everyone is entitiled to an opinion, a five though? I reckon you are setting traps TM!

[Smokey]

Gave him a 9 but wanted to give him an 8.5.  Good year from Lids but still room for improvement.

[yellowandback]

his season was nothing exciting a 5

Everyone is entitiled to an opinion, a five though? I reckon you are setting traps TM!

he's being funny but not "haha"

[Tigermad20011]

Great year and a great player AA next year for sure.

[Hellenic Tiger]

his season was nothing exciting a 5

hahahahaha 

Of course it was.

Yep he played boring stable conservative footy off half back. I gave him an 8.

[eliminator]

had a good year. His long kicking is a delight to watch.

[Mr Magic]

I'd give Lids an 8.5.
His season was right up there with Jack's IMO.
Contested marking and disposal a delight off HB. Goddard like.
Think Dimma uses him beautifully & thought it was Brett's best year at Richmond so far.

[Con65]

his season was nothing exciting a 5

I thought this year was far better than the 2 previous when he won the Jack.  I gave him an 8.

TM..care to elaborate why you think it was nothing exciting and only a 5.  What are you judging him against?