Rate a Tiger's year - 24. Andrew Collins?

[gerkin greg]

I'm giving him a 5 as well Margaret.

[Jacosh]

Got a 5 from me, only just.  As many have said the gap between good and bad is way to big and he needs to put some meat on those bones.  Looks like a 12 year old out playing with his dad.

[Francois Jackson]

love the way he goes about it.

will be a very good player for our football club

[Mr Magic]

Interesting to see in how most saw Andrew's season before he was a muted trade.
Geez the way some are carrying on around the place you'd think he was seen as a superstar. ???

[mat073]

Interesting to see in how most saw Andrew's season before he was a muted trade.
Geez the way some are carrying on around the place you'd think he was seen as a superstar. ???

Spot on Mr Magic.

If you look up the word "expendable" in the dictionary there may be a photo of Andrew Collins next to it.

[tdy]

Interesting to see in how most saw Andrew's season before he was a muted trade.
Geez the way some are carrying on around the place you'd think he was seen as a superstar. ???

Its just the rest of the list is only 5 and 6 ers too, so he looks pretty good in comparison.  He probably will make it at Carlton, but not a huge loss for us, as I doubt he will be a star.

[Judge Roughneck]

Then the following in mix for mid size role;
taylor, Morton, dea, Oreilly, webberly, Connors, tambling, farmer, nason, Hicks, king, White, Edwards etc.

Does not have to worry about Hicks, Oreilly. Both should not be on the list both should be just retained as rookies.

i would be happy for oreilly to be on the senior list.

hopfully in 2012 he will be

[Carvels Ring]

4 from me.  did improve, but still didnt do much.  Everyone is basing their opinions on his last qtr against the swans. pfft

[Stripes]

Can we stop discussing Andy Collins! It's like ypur just broke up with a girl and all you can talk about with your new missus is how good the old girl was!  I'm no expert, but this doesn't make for a good start to a relationship in my view