haarrggh of course i rate hardwick i just dont rate shank edwards. hardwick could be god almighty himself and not even god could fix edwards weaknesses.
some decent coaches have gone by the wayside at richmond trying to do the impossible with players rather than just cutting them loose. simple put you cant build it if you aint got the tools.
Got something in your throat? 
You focus on Edwards weaknesses but perhaps his coach sees his strengths and that's why he keeps playing him. 
BTW Shane's 2010 season was substantially better than any Fiona ever produced. That's why I said the comment was stupid.
If Edwards falls over this year after a strong pre season(unlike last year), I'll graciously admit you were right about him.
Until then I still have hope he can build on the clear improvement he showed a season back..
A post full of reason! Well done. I can see why supporters don't like titch however i thik he can make it. In fact he already has!
