Richmond vs GWS @ Giants Stadium --- Round 12, 2023

[WilliamPowell]

So Kingsley gave no votes to Taranto?

You're assuming Mini gave Taranto 5

They certainly are strange votes

[mightytiges]

So Kingsley gave no votes to Taranto?

You're assuming Mini gave Taranto 5

They certainly are strange votes

Yep, so many possible combos it's impossible to know.

One possibility:
Jack  5     Balta 5
Taranto 4  Bolton 4
Green 3    Ward 3
Ward 2     Jack 2
Bolton 1   Taranto 1

Another is:
Taranto 5   Ward 5
Jack 4        Bolton 4
Balta 3       Jack 3
Green 2      Balta 2
Bolton 1      Green 1

It all depends on who out of Jack, Taranto, Bolton, Balta and Ward received 5 votes.

[one-eyed]

We only won because of the umps according to Gerard Healy

-------------------

Stopping short of saying both winners were undeserving, Healy suggested that poor umpiring decisions perhaps swung the games in the way of the victors.

“Both winners were on the end of dodgy decisions in the last quarter that fell the right way,” he told SEN’s Sportsday.

Healy explained that Harry Himmelberg was wrongly accused of kicking the ball out on the full, a decision that led to Jack Riewoldt kicking his fifth goal of the game.

He also believes Jesse Hogan didn’t receive a deserved push in the back decision in the final term. Richmond defeated the Giants by just six points.

https://www.sen.com.au/news/2023/06/05/cost-clubs-four-points-healy-calls-out-poor-decisions-from-late-in-sunday/

[Andyy]

What was wrong with HH OOTF? Looked clear cut to me?

[Damo]

What was wrong with HH OOTF? Looked clear cut to me?

Came off his foot and into the ground
100% the wrong call , but we will take it lol

[WilliamPowell]

What was wrong with HH OOTF? Looked clear cut to me?

Came off his foot and into the ground
100% the wrong call , but we will take it lol

Agree Damo

With umpiring it is "swings and roundabouts" .

We got that one but didn't get the Whitfield HTB but GWS got HTB against Dan Rioli and not the Hogan one

Happens every week

Gerard obviously needed something to talk about

[Andyy]

What was wrong with HH OOTF? Looked clear cut to me?

Came off his foot and into the ground
100% the wrong call , but we will take it lol

Agree Damo

With umpiring it is "swings and roundabouts" .

We got that one but didn't get the Whitfield HTB but GWS got HTB against Dan Rioli and not the Hogan one

Happens every week

Gerard obviously needed something to talk about

I was watching Kayo on my phone at the in-laws so didn't see it too closely. At a glance I thought it was OOTF.

Like you said I'll take it haha. GWS got some crap decisions too sheesh