Rate a Tiger's year - 10. Shane Edwards?

[mat073]

Wallace trying to reinvent Edwards as a backman was not the best move.

[bushranger]

I think you could almost say that what Wallace done for Richmond in total wasn't too good.

[Mr Magic]

6 for me.

First half of the year very disappointing but showed plenty more once Wallet left the building.
Just needs concentrated development. He's a commer IMO.

[Francois Jackson]

2/10

how he can be classified as a half back is beyond me

Trade

[Tigermonk]

2/10

how he can be classified as a half back is beyond me

Trade

just kick him out the door his not a league footballer to start with, his a 2 minute noodle 

[Francois Jackson]

2/10

how he can be classified as a half back is beyond me

Trade

just kick him out the door his not a league footballer to start with, his a 2 minute noodle 

thats why we get laughed at as a football club TM.

Edwards as skinny as Nahas yet Nahas can tackle an opponent to the ground and kick the goals.

Edwards should have been traded IMO.

Lethal used to tell his players when they played us "we were like an egg, crush them and they are all mushy inside"

Thats because we have players like Edwards in our team

get rid of him or play him on the HFF at the very least

[Tigermonk]

2/10

how he can be classified as a half back is beyond me

Trade

just kick him out the door his not a league footballer to start with, his a 2 minute noodle 

thats why we get laughed at as a football club TM.

Edwards as skinny as Nahas yet Nahas can tackle an opponent to the ground and kick the goals.

Edwards should have been traded IMO.

Lethal used to tell his players when they played us "we were like an egg, crush them and they are all mushy inside"

Thats because we have players like Edwards in our team

get rid of him or play him on the HFF at the very least

his backline attemps are as good as Mclovin 
he can play forward so dont know why his down back

[Judge Roughneck]

Give me more time FFS

[Chuck17]

Give me more time FFS

Take as much time as you like Bentleigh, its an internet forum no rush.

[Judge Roughneck]

Give me more time FFS

Take as much time as you like Bentleigh, its an internet forum no rush.

him*

Edwards was drafted in 06 and was SA #2 best mid behind Gibbs

he has potential to be a good small forward

not even started his 4th pre-season

[WA Tiger]

-1 for mine and he was lucky to get that, he has potential to be a good jocky and thats about it. Schulz and Hughes had potential to be good forwards as well, big or small the three are the same.......

[Judge Roughneck]

Schultz was drafted in 02

Edwards 06

[WA Tiger]

Schultz was drafted in 02

Edwards 06

Great so we can look forward to 4 more years of pain watching him like we did Schulz?? Look he showed a bit under Rawlings and I will give him that but he needs to lift by another 40% to even stay in the side. Lets hope he has it in him next year.