OER PHANTOM DRAFT 2009

[TigerLand]

Collingwood

Pick 62: Matthew Scott (Eastern Ranges / Vic Metro)
Silky skilled midfielder off both feet, and very sure hands with nice height.
Height: 185  Weight: 71

Needs some bulk and work on his engine to play well at AFL level.

http://rangesfc.matchvision.com.au/player/matthew_scott

[one-eyed]

Update...

1. Melbourne - Jack Trengove
2. Melbourne - Tom Scully
3. Richmond - Dustin Martin
4. Fremantle - Anthony Morabito
5. North Melb - Ben Cunnington
6. Sydney      - Gary Rohan
7. West Coast - John Butcher
8. Port Adelaide - Jake Carlisle
9. Port Adelaide - Kane Lucas
10. Essendon - Aaron Black
11. Melbourne - Daniel Talia
12. Carlton - Jordan Gysberts
13. Adelaide - Ryan Bastinac
14. Sydney - Lewis Jetta
15. Bulldogs - Luke Tapscott
16. Port Adelaide - Jake Melksham
17. Geelong - Nathan Vardy

18. Melbourne - Andrew Moore
19. Richmond - Ben Griffiths
20. Fremantle - Joel Houghton
21. North Melb - Matthew Panos
22. West Coast - Brad Sheppard
23. West Coast - Callum Bartlett
24. Essendon - Koby Stevens
25. North Melb - Mark Hutchings
26. Essendon - Marcus Davies
27. Brisbane - Josh Thomas
28. Geelong - Kyle Hartigan
29. Adelaide - Troy Taylor
30. Collingwood - Luke Ball
31. Bulldogs - Jack Fitzpatrick
32. St Kilda - Mitchell Duncan
33. Essendon - Sam Reid

34. Melbourne - Daniel Menzel
35. Richmond - Mitch Fisher
36. Fremantle - Allen Christensen
37. North Melb - Dylan Grimes
38. Sydney - Ryan Harwood
39. Hawthorn - Max Gawn
40. Geelong - Joe Dare
41. North Melb - Myles Sewell
42. Geelong - Andrew Hooper
43. Carlton - Matt Maguire
44. Richmond - Warwick McGinty
45. Adelaide - Travis Colyer
46. Hawthorn - Sam Shaw
47. Brisbane - David Astbury
48. Fremantle - Roland Ah Chee
49. Fremantle - James Craig

50. Melbourne - Serhat Temel
51. Richmond - Josh Cowan
52. Fremantle - Jarryd Amalfi
53. North Melb - Alex Carey
54. Sydney - Todd Culley
55. Sydney - Sam Ezard
56. Geelong - Levi Casboult
57. Hawthorn - Jesse Crichton
58. Hawthorn - Jasper McMillan-Pittard
59. Carlton - Jesse Smith
60. St Kilda - Nathan Fyfe
61. Adelaide - Majak Daw
62. Collingwood - Matthew Scott


Next is Gordon Bennett and his Bulldogs' pick 63

[Gordon Bennett]

pick 63 Mitch Thorp

An element of risk, given that he's injury-prone, an obvious jackass, and has not lived up to his potential as a no.6 draft pick. However, still reasonable value at a pick in the 60's.

Others in consideration were Tom Hill, N.Winmar,and  Dylan McNeil

[one-eyed]

64. St Kilda - Nicholas Winmar (Claremont, 27/04/91, 190cm, 78kg)

Although not a direct relative to his famous namesake there's a bit of romanticism in having another Nicky Winmar in red, white and black. Very agile HFF with good skills, Winmar is an X-factor type who would be very hard for opposition clubs to match-up on at his height. The knock on him are a question mark over his work ethic but at a late pick he's worth the risk.

[wayne]

Melbourne - PASS

[mightytiges]

Ramps said he'll be mostly away today and possibly tomorrow and he asked if I could do the pick for him. So blame me for this pick lol.

67. Richmond - Jaryd Cachia (Northern Knights Vic, 08-May-1991, 184cm, 83kg)

Solid inside midfielder who is a thumping right foot kick and looks like an old-fashioned footballer. Averaged 19 disposals and was top 10 in clearances and contested possessions at TAC Cup. He scored 2.95 sec for 20m sprint & level 13-9 shuttle at the Victorian state screening.

Video

[tiga]

At pick #68, Fremantle would like to select

Luke Ablett, Sydney Swans

We are looking to bolster our midfield ranks with a ready made tagger. We believe Luke's run of injuries are now behind him and he is ready to rejuvenate his career.
To pick up a 27 year old player with substantial premiership experience using such a late draft pick is an absolute bonus.

[Infamy]

69 - Hawthorn - Pass

Hawks will continue to have a variety of ruckmen train with them until December so that they can make the best decision on who to pick up in the PSD

[Ramps]

Ramps said he'll be mostly away today and possibly tomorrow and he asked if I could do the pick for him. So blame me for this pick lol.

67. Richmond - Jaryd Cachia (Northern Knights Vic, 08-May-1991, 184cm, 83kg)

Solid inside midfielder who is a thumping right foot kick and looks like an old-fashioned footballer. Averaged 19 disposals and was top 10 in clearances and contested possessions at TAC Cup. He scored 2.95 sec for 20m sprint & level 13-9 shuttle at the Victorian state screening.

Video

Dud selection here 

[mightytiges]

Ramps said he'll be mostly away today and possibly tomorrow and he asked if I could do the pick for him. So blame me for this pick lol.

67. Richmond - Jaryd Cachia (Northern Knights Vic, 08-May-1991, 184cm, 83kg)

Solid inside midfielder who is a thumping right foot kick and looks like an old-fashioned footballer. Averaged 19 disposals and was top 10 in clearances and contested possessions at TAC Cup. He scored 2.95 sec for 20m sprint & level 13-9 shuttle at the Victorian state screening.

Video

Dud selection here 

At least Cachia won't be another Fiora who can't put weight on lol. Solidly built body for a 18 year old and fills a need (inside mid). Worth the risk this late in the draft. Only question mark is kicking on his non-dominant side - can he kick with his left?

It's your turn Ramps. We'll be gentle

[Ramps]

With our next pick, Richmond selects young Sth Fremantle Colts Vice Captain- Mitch Carter. At 183cm and 75kgs hes about the right size for a half back flank, half forward flank, needs to put on about 8 kgs but should be able to do so. Quick over the 20 metres, runs the lines well, kicks well, brings some leadership skills to the table. Very happy to have Mitch at Richmond.

[mightytiges]

With our next pick, Richmond selects young Sth Fremantle Colts Vice Captain- Mitch Carter. At 183cm and 75kgs hes about the right size for a half back flank, half forward flank, needs to put on about 8 kgs but should be able to do so. Quick over the 20 metres, runs the lines well, kicks well, brings some leadership skills to the table. Very happy to have Mitch at Richmond.

We'll be called Mitchmond with so many Mitches  . Carter has a very natural and reliable kick by the looks of him in the highlights. Moves a bit like Newy.

[mightytiges]

73. Brisbane - Matt Dea (North Ballarat Rebels, 13/10/91, 186cm, 82kg)

Midfielder and midsized rebounding defender. Has good awareness and an excellent leap coming from a basketball background where he was captain of the U18 Country Victorian team which allows him to play taller when in defence. Decent skills and a good size already. Scored 2.93 secs for the 20m sprint at the Vic screening and 74cm standing jump which is in the top 8%. Worth a late pick.

http://offseasondraft.championdata.com/afl_off_season_draft/offSeasonDraft/player_profile.jsp?player_id=116140

[Ramps]

With our next pick, Richmond selects young Sth Fremantle Colts Vice Captain- Mitch Carter. At 183cm and 75kgs hes about the right size for a half back flank, half forward flank, needs to put on about 8 kgs but should be able to do so. Quick over the 20 metres, runs the lines well, kicks well, brings some leadership skills to the table. Very happy to have Mitch at Richmond.

We'll be called Mitchmond with so many Mitches  . Carter has a very natural and reliable kick by the looks of him in the highlights. Moves a bit like Newy.

Yeah what was it with parents around 18 years ago. Anyone have any idea why Mitch became a popular name?

[TigerLand]

Collingwood Pick 73

Tom Harms (Sturt SA)

In and Outside midfielder who has grown up in Trengoves shadow
Was rated equal 3rd best in the kicking drill at draft camp. Has a huge right shoe on him and can kick goals from well outside 50. He's a goal kicking midfielder that gets plenty of pill.
With big long blonde dreadlocks this kid will be a bigger cult figure than Dale Thomas and a bargain at pick 73.