2010 Rising Star Award [merged]

[Infamy]

So let me get this right.
He was reprimanded and considered ineligible (round 3).

Yet after this he was still nominated (round 10).

With the panel knowing full well that he is not eligible to poll any votes, even though he may well be the best young talent.
My question is this.

Why bother in the first place you morons ?!?!

Because his old junior club gets a cash prize, the reprimand stops him from winning the whole thing, but can still be nominated

Thanks Inf.
Still reckon he should still be able to collect votes, even if not eligible ( same as brownlow).
If recognition is deserved it should be delivered.

I do kinda agree, but given all the votes are given after Round 22 when each member ranks their top 5 nominees it's a bit pointless to give votes to a player who can't win

[The Big Richo]

Because his old junior club gets a cash prize, the reprimand stops him from winning the whole thing, but can still be nominated

Yep, spot on. I'm from his old club and we received cash and contra in exchange for a fluff piece in the local rag saying how great the NAB is.

Good to see you are still about BTW, Infamy. 

[one-eyed]

No votes for Dusty. Hannebery won the Rising Star with the maximum 45 votes.

2010 voting
Daniel Hannebery    45 ------- Winner
Tom Scully        35
Tom Rockliff        24
Jack Trengove        11
Ryan Bastinac        6
Jeff Garlett        5
Nathan Fyfe        3
Michael Hurley    2
Nic Naitanui        2
Ben Reid        1
Ben Stratton        1

Andrew Demetriou
5 - Daniel Hannebery
4 - Tom Scully
3 - Tom Rockliff
2 - Jack Trengove
1 - Nathan Fyfe

Adrian Anderson
5 - Daniel Hannebery
4 - Tom Scully
3 - Tom Rockliff
2 - Jack Trengove
1 - Ben Stratton

James Hird
5 - Daniel Hannebery
4 - Tom Scully
3 - Jack Trengove
2 - Tom Rockliff
1 - Nathan Fyfe

Kevin Bartlett
5 - Daniel Hannebery
4 - Tom Scully
3 - Tom Rockliff
2 - Michael Hurley
1 - Ryan Bastinac

Mark Riccuito
5 - Daniel Hannebery
4 - Tom Scully
3 - Ryan Bastinac
2 - Jack Trengove
1 - Tom Rockliff

Gerard Healy
5 - Daniel Hannebery
4 - Tom Rockliff
3 - Tom Scully
2 - Jack Trengove
1 - Nathan Fyfe

Glen Jakovich
5 - Daniel Hannebery
4 - Tom Scully
3 - Jeff Garlett
2 - Tom Rockliff
1 - Nic Naitanui

Kevin Sheehan
5 - Daniel Hannebery
4 - Tom Scully
3 - Tom Rockliff
2 - Ryan Bastinac
1 - Nic Naitanui

Robert Walls
5 - Daniel Hannebery
4 - Tom Scully
3 - Tom Rockliff
2 - Jeff Garlett
1 - Ben Reid

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/101684/default.aspx

[wayne]

hmmm... Nic Natanui getting some votes....  ???

[one-eyed]

Martin (top left) at the RS function today with the other nominees

[gerkin greg]

Well done Danny Hanny. I think he may even have edged it if Marto was eligible.
Also wiped the smile off those tanking toff idiots at Melbourne.

[1965]

Well done Danny Hanny. I think he may even have edged it if Marto was eligible.
Also wiped the smile off those tanking toff idiots at Melbourne.

95 posts in 8 days.

You must be unemployed or a Yr 9 student with a laptop not paying attention in class.

God help us all.

What did you do to get kicked off Y&B?

 

[Carvels Ring]

'65 i am with ya buddy, i am with ya! 

[mightytiges]

Stick to the topic ppl!


Hannebery is a deserving winner as he's had a great season. Having said that a 4th in the RFC B&F for Martin last night demonstrated Dusty's great year also and he would've been hard to beat in the RS if he was eligible. Interesting to see where the other RS nominees finish in their respective Club B&Fs as a comparison.

[gerkin greg]

95 posts in 8 days.
96
You must be unemployed or a Yr 9 student with a laptop not paying attention in class.
I must be
God help us all.
Richo wont save you
What did you do to get kicked off Y&B?
It wasn't pedophilia
 
 

[Coach]

Well done Danny Hanny. I think he may even have edged it if Marto was eligible.
Also wiped the smile off those tanking toff idiots at Melbourne.

95 posts in 8 days.

You must be unemployed or a Yr 9 student with a laptop not paying attention in class.

God help us all.

What did you do to get kicked off Y&B?

 

You a bit angry, lad? What you doing here? WAT is in the bedroom with the strap on  


 


Well done to Hannebery

[Owl]

Well done Danny Hanny. I think he may even have edged it if Marto was eligible.
Also wiped the smile off those tanking toff idiots at Melbourne.

95 posts in 8 days.

You must be unemployed or a Yr 9 student with a laptop not paying attention in class.

God help us all.

What did you do to get kicked off Y&B?

 

Go and take a shower mate, get some of that sand out of your bagina.

[Chuck17]

Martin (top left) at the RS function today with the other nominees

I reckon Martin looks like he wouldnt mind giving it to half the sftckcs in that photo including the one with the ugly piece of crap on his head.

[Smokey]

So with 22 nominees how come only 17 in the official photo?

[mightytiges]

So with 22 nominees how come only 17 in the official photo?

No Morabito in that photo so I'm guessing travel. Same with Fyfe? Ben Reid not there either so perhaps training as well.