bottom line is that it doesn't matter where they have it people are going to be unhappy.
What's the old saying? You can't please everyone
For me Jell's Park was an hour + trip
Craigieburn is 40 mins if the ring road is good
So it's not like either is around the corner for me
But as bojangles mentions the Club is investing in the Craigieburn - seriously you cannot expect to have a brand new state of the art facility given to you for $0 without having to give back something in return
As for the handing over the SE burbs to Hawthorn - the supporters Richmond have are there they aren't going anywhere - they've had the last what is it 5 or so family days out there, they have the Wantrina Club . You could almost use the same argument for every area in Melbourne.
Craigieburn is one of the fastest growing areas in the Metro area - so there is a massive untapped market there, the club would be crazy not to target it.
In a perfect world it should be at Punt Road but while cricket is played there during summer it is near impossible to schedule a family day at our HOME...