Pick one: Brett Deleldio or Ryan Griffin? (Herald-Sun)

[Owl]

thats all good but were discussing Deledio and and Griffin in this thread as per the heading.

[Judge Roughneck]

There is no realistic debate here - LIds by a country-mile on talent, skills and, most importantly in these such comparisons, achievements.

At better comparison would be between Lids and Buddy.

Stripes

buddy=match winner
Lids is not.......yet

Buddy by a mile at this stage

Deledio would kick 80+ goals a year if he played for Hawthorn or Footscray IMO ..

[Hellenic Tiger]

There is no realistic debate here - LIds by a country-mile on talent, skills and, most importantly in these such comparisons, achievements.

At better comparison would be between Lids and Buddy.

Stripes

buddy=match winner
Lids is not.......yet

Buddy by a mile at this stage

Deledio would kick 80+ goals a year if he played for Hawthorn or Footscray IMO ..

From the midfield???

[Chuck17]

From the midfield???

Nah from the half back line, Lids is a super freak it is just the rest of the spuds in our side dragging him down

[Ramps]

this may seem tough on griffen but he looks like a tourist in the bullies side, getting carried along on a great ride, its seems hes doing it easy, if deledio was at the bullies people would see the difference, atleast 3 classes a better player imho.

[Judge Roughneck]

There is no realistic debate here - LIds by a country-mile on talent, skills and, most importantly in these such comparisons, achievements.

At better comparison would be between Lids and Buddy.

Stripes

buddy=match winner
Lids is not.......yet

Buddy by a mile at this stage

Deledio would kick 80+ goals a year if he played for Hawthorn or Footscray IMO ..

From the midfield???

If Deledio was in a good football team with an already strong midfeild  ie. Geelong / St Kilda

they would use him in the forward line

[Tigermonk]

l have yet to see Deledio hurt any side, He will never kick 80 goals in any side cause his a lazy prick

[TigerTimeII]

l have yet to see Deledio hurt any side, He will never kick 80 goals in any side cause his a lazy prick

its not just laziness, its the im too good for this attitude, he thinks cos he was a gun jnr and no1 pick his poo dont stink

he needs too look at nason and martin, they were not no1 picks but they have attitude and desire

[Infamy]

l have yet to see Deledio hurt any side, He will never kick 80 goals in any side cause his a lazy prick

When was the last time a 188cm midfielder/utility ever kicked 80 goals in a season?

[TigerTimeII]

l have yet to see Deledio hurt any side, He will never kick 80 goals in any side cause his a lazy prick

When was the last time a 188cm midfielder/utility ever kicked 80 goals in a season?

tigermonk never said that
Bentleigh-esque is the tosser who said that

however, edwards dad was a gun indiginous player, i am sure he kicked over 100 goals in a season in the sanfl and he was a rover , absolute gun

[Judge Roughneck]

l have yet to see Deledio hurt any side,

did you watch the 3rd quarter of richmond vs geelong, in geelong last season?

[Infamy]

l have yet to see Deledio hurt any side, He will never kick 80 goals in any side cause his a lazy prick

When was the last time a 188cm midfielder/utility ever kicked 80 goals in a season?

tigermonk never said that
Bentleigh-esque is the tosser who said that

I realise that but it was the last comment made on the topic, so it was the post I quoted
It was addressed to anyone who wants to answer it

[Judge Roughneck]

l have yet to see Deledio hurt any side, He will never kick 80 goals in any side cause his a lazy prick

When was the last time a 188cm midfielder/utility ever kicked 80 goals in a season?

Goddard would kick 80 goals if St Kilda left him in the forward line.

Deledio would do the same in a top 4 team

[Infamy]

l have yet to see Deledio hurt any side, He will never kick 80 goals in any side cause his a lazy prick

When was the last time a 188cm midfielder/utility ever kicked 80 goals in a season?

Goddard would kick 80 goals if St Kilda left him in the forward line.

Deledio would do the same in a top 4 team

With or without Riewoldt?

[TigerTimeII]

l have yet to see Deledio hurt any side, He will never kick 80 goals in any side cause his a lazy prick

When was the last time a 188cm midfielder/utility ever kicked 80 goals in a season?

Goddard would kick 80 goals if St Kilda left him in the forward line.

Deledio would do the same in a top 4 team

at this pt in time , deledio is not even goggards shoe laces

goddard has that competitive , the desire to win and backs his own skill . he takes the game on , does not play in his shell or comfort zone as lids does

if lids dared to take the game on he could be as good as goddard