Changes next week for the Swannies game?

[Go Richo 12]

Conners couldnt possibly come up!

[tigersalive]

we have no rucks simmonds, graham and browne not up to it imho. vickery needs time, in november we should pick up a 25yo bash and crash type ruck out of a state league with our last pick and then another 1 in the psd.

Should of picked up Mumford, pointless talking about it now though

And trade another early draft pick?  No thanks.  No way I would I be happy if Richmond bettered the Swans pick 28 to get him given we needed all the picks we had to get some quality early (i.e. Griffiths and Astbury).

[bojangles17]

we have no rucks simmonds, graham and browne not up to it imho. vickery needs time, in november we should pick up a 25yo bash and crash type ruck out of a state league with our last pick and then another 1 in the psd.

i was advocating that for last 2 drafts, for mine cartledge wasn't given enough of a go...

[Infamy]

after watching coburg on sat.
couldnt possibly play Browne, Graham, Rance.

Let's stick with Simmonds then, because he's in such scintillating form, and is obviously the future of our club.

Mate, if you think Simmonds is bad, you should look at the other 2.
It took Graham 3 games to get a possesion .
And I cannot understand why Graham spent 70% of each quarter on the ground and Browne 30% at Coburg on sat
Need to keep both on the ground for a long as possible, both struggle with endurance

At least Graham & Browne have a chance of improving, Simmo is getting worse
Given Simmo's output in the last 2 games I'd rather Graham playing anyway, they offer about the same

[Siberian]

Simmons can only play full forward
Graham cant play anywhere
polak for the ruck, desperate times, desperate measures!

[torch]

In (Out):

Roberts (King), Polo (Nahas), Browne (Simmonds), Webberley (Edwards), Astbury (Hislop)

Team:

B: Farmer, Thursfield, Moore

HB: Webberley, McGuane, Deledio

C: Nason, Newman, Martin

HF: Polo, Riewoldt, Tambling

F: Morton, Post, Roberts

Ruck: Vickery

Ruck Rover: Thomson

Rover: Jackson

Int: Cotchin, Browne, Astbury, Connors

[Siberian]

I like Newman in the centre, it has to happen, not sure about Roberts back, is all forgiven?

[torch]

I like Newman in the centre, it has to happen, not sure about Roberts back, is all forgiven?

i hope Newman does play in the midfield but i think Hardwick would see this as a "Quick Fix" which he do not like.

just like playing Simmonds at full forward is a "Quick Fix"!

Roberts was suspended for 1 week, so i am assuming all is "OK" with him, hoping Roberts appreciates the opportunity he has.

 

[Siberian]

agree about newman, best for the moment but not long term solution, but simmons at full forward is more about Jack than simmons or even the overall result, he is thrown to the wolves all alone down there

[Danog]

I would like to see something like this next round.

B:    Moore         Thursfield     Connors
HB:  Webberley   McGuane      Tambling
C:    Cotchin       Jackson       Newman
HF:  Polo            Riewoldt       Nason
F:    Morton        Post            Rance
Foll: Simmonds    Deledio         Martin
Int:  Dea Thomson Vickery Roberts
Emg: Browne Edwards Tuck

Out: Edwards, Farmer, Hislop, King, Nahas
In: Dea, Webberley, Polo, Rance, Roberts

Average height of outs: 179cm
Average height of ins: 185cm

[TigerTimeII]

I would like to see something like this next round.

B:    Moore         Thursfield     Connors
HB:  Webberley   McGuane      Tambling
C:    Cotchin       POLO          Newman
HF:  ROBERTS     Riewoldt       COUSINS
F:    Morton        Post            TAYLOR
Foll: BROWNE      Deledio         Martin
Int:  TUCK  EDWARDS  NASON   Vickery

THATS MY TEAM 4 NEXT WEEK

[Danog]

Any reason for Nason and Edwards being highlighted?

[Danog]

I'm not seeing why people want Thomson out of the team for Tuck.  Tuck still isn't doing the team-oriented stuff.  That's why he's playing at half-back at Coburg.  He needs to be more accountable. 

Thomson is doing the right things at the moment.  He has 83% disposal efficiency, had 4 clearances, and only 1 clanger against the Dogs.  Dimma should persist with him for a bit longer.

[Gigantor]

Why should Roberts come straight back in?Did he do enough round one?......I thoughout his performance against Carlton was serviceable at best

[TigerTimeII]

Any reason for Nason and Edwards being highlighted?

no reason , just buggered that up