Top 3 in the B&F?

[yellowandback]

At the halfway mark who would be vying for the top 3 in our B&F

Jack, Dusty, Cotch and Lids would most likely be the obvious candidates but Tuck has been a sensation since coming into the side with Edwards, Newman and Moore pushing their case despite sporadic form and fitness.

[Hellenic Tiger]

Right now I would say

1 Riewoldt
2 Deledio
3 Cotchin

[tony_montana]

Tuck and deledio ahead

Jack closing

[WilliamPowell]

I would think the top 3 would be out of

Cotchin
Deledio
Reiwoldt

With Tuck & Edwards rounding out the top 5

[bojangles17]

In order:
Lids
Newman(with a bullet)
JR8
space
martin
cotch
edwards

[tony_montana]

In order:
Lids
Newman(with a bullet)
JR8
space
martin
cotch
edwards

no tuck Bo?

geez hard marker...

[eliminator]

Jack then Tuck and Brett. Moore, Martin and Newman are definitely in the mix

[bojangles17]

In order:
Lids
Newman(with a bullet)
JR8
space
martin
cotch
edwards

no tuck Bo?

geez hard marker...

sorry an ommission, tuck would replace edwards on my order

[Muscles]

In order;

1.  Cotchin by a nose from ...
2.  Tuck, closely followed by ...
3.  Reiwoldt, then a gap to ...

Newman, Martin, Moore and Lids in a bunch ...

with the rest trailing off ...

[Smokey]

Deledio
Cotchin
Newman
Riewoldt
Tuck
Martin
Jackson

and by the end of the year:

Deledio
Cotchin
Riewoldt
Newman
Jackson
Martin
Tuck

[tony_montana]

hmm, I'm not trying to start an argument but I honestly wouldn't have cotchin in the top 5 at this stage let alone top 2 or 3.

Lids, tuck, reiwoldt, newman and martin have all been better imo. Cotch had a very slow start to this season  due to a limited pre season and is only now starting to get match fitness up to a level where he can influence games. I expect him to come home like a steam train but to date, not even close

[yellowandback]

hmm, I'm not trying to start an argument but I honestly wouldn't have cotchin in the top 5 at this stage let alone top 2 or 3.

Lids, tuck, reiwoldt, newman and martin have all been better imo. Cotch had a very slow start to this season  due to a limited pre season and is only now starting to get match fitness up to a level where he can influence games. I expect him to come home like a steam train but to date, not even close

his last month has been pretty good and that has coincided with our teams improved form. I reckon that would help him

[bojangles17]

hmm, I'm not trying to start an argument but I honestly wouldn't have cotchin in the top 5 at this stage let alone top 2 or 3.

Lids, tuck, reiwoldt, newman and martin have all been better imo. Cotch had a very slow start to this season  due to a limited pre season and is only now starting to get match fitness up to a level where he can influence games. I expect him to come home like a steam train but to date, not even close

agreed cotch would have only troubled the scorerers in last mth..I should ommit him...Lids by a fair way for mine, with Newy and JR8 closing the gap...from a RFC point of view Lids hasnt played too many bad games

[mightytiges]

1. Lids ... our 'quarterback' who sets up attacks off HB similar to Hodge at Hawthorn
2. Jack ... for obvious reasons (leading the Coleman)
3. Newy ... even WP is giving him plenty of votes this season so he must be doing well

Martin, Cotch and Tucky next in line.

[Fluffy Tiger]

1. Lids ... our 'quarterback' who sets up attacks off HB similar to Hodge at Hawthorn
2. Jack ... for obvious reasons (leading the Coleman)
3. Newy ... even WP is giving him plenty of votes this season so he must be doing well

Martin, Cotch and Tucky next in line.

Ill go with this

+1