Brownlow medal thread [merged]

[Hellenic Tiger]

Judd another 3 votes and Swan, Ablett nil. leads by 5 with just 3 rounds to go

Judd going to hard to toss now.

Should have been suspended after he made Pavlich bleed. I smell a conspiracy.  

The AFL Golden Child prevails.

Was not BOG against us in round 20.

[one-eyed]

Judd's won it!


Round 22 vs Port

1. Morton



Tiger final tally:
Lids      7
Jack     7
Martin   6
Tuck    4
Newy    3
Connors 3
Cotch   2
Cuz      2
Jacko    2
Morton  1

[Ox]

Awesome seeing eddie gutted and Swan trying not to cry.

LOL - Now for the GF failure !

[one-eyed]

Final Leaderboard:

Judd          30
Ablett        26
Swan         24
Pendlebury  21
Selwood     21
Boyd          20
Sandilands  20
Hayes        19


Tigers final tally:
Lids      7
Jack     7
Martin   6
Tuck     4
Newy    3
Connors 3
Cotch   2
Cuz      2
Jacko    2
Morton  1

[mightytiges]

Congrats to Judd. 

The AFL would have preferred it if Ablett had won it just as he was heading to the Gold Coast. 

Awesome seeing eddie gutted and Swan trying not to cry.

LOL - Now for the GF failure !

 

[TigerLand]

Judd another 3 votes and Swan, Ablett nil. leads by 5 with just 3 rounds to go

Judd going to hard to toss now.

Should have been suspended after he made Pavlich bleed. I smell a conspiracy.  

The AFL Golden Child prevails.

Was not BOG against us in round 20.

It's the umpires award TB.

Barlow Round 1 33 possessions and 2 goals in debut = 0 votes.

Its opinion based. Umpires opinion award. Happier to see someone like Judd win a Brownlow then a Cooney or Goodes.

He's the best player in the comp.

[jackstar is back again]

Awesome seeing eddie gutted and Swan trying not to cry.

LOL - Now for the GF failure !

Totally agree, Eddie sore loser

[jackstar is back again]

Judd another 3 votes and Swan, Ablett nil. leads by 5 with just 3 rounds to go

Judd going to hard to toss now.

Should have been suspended after he made Pavlich bleed. I smell a conspiracy.  

The AFL Golden Child prevails.

Was not BOG against us in round 20.

Just reminder you, Judd mised the first 3 rounds

[Hellenic Tiger]

Judd another 3 votes and Swan, Ablett nil. leads by 5 with just 3 rounds to go

Judd going to hard to toss now.

Should have been suspended after he made Pavlich bleed. I smell a conspiracy.  

The AFL Golden Child prevails.

Was not BOG against us in round 20.

Just reminder you, Judd mised the first 3 rounds

Yep aware of that Jack.
Good luck to him. Just thought he should have been suspended.
I just hate Carlton.
Still Eddie's face was priceless too.

[Ramps]

Awesome seeing eddie gutted and Swan trying not to cry.

LOL - Now for the GF failure !

And I thought I was seeing things. Swan was on the verge of it and McGuire was thinking the same old - there all out to get collingwood poo.

[Rodgerramjet]

What an utter farce, Judd is not the best and fairest player in the league, not by a long way, 4 years ago maybe, but not today. I swear this game is getting more rigged by the year with contrived outcomes, It happens on feild as well as off. stuff me dead.

[Rodgerramjet]

Awesome seeing eddie gutted and Swan trying not to cry.

LOL - Now for the GF failure !

And I thought I was seeing things. Swan was on the verge of it and McGuire was thinking the same old - there all out to get collingwood poo.

I'll say this ramps if Mguire was upset with Judd winning as opposed to Swan losing then I agree with him. I just wonder who at AFL house is sucking Judds idiot.

[Smokey]

What an utter farce, Judd is not the best and fairest player in the league, not by a long way, 4 years ago maybe, but not today. I swear this game is getting more rigged by the year with contrived outcomes, It happens on feild as well as off. eff me dead.

I have to say I'm unable to mount an argument against you RRJ.  There is no way in the wide world Judd was the best player in our competition this year and there is no way he should not have been reported and rubbed out for the strike on Pavlich.  King or Jackson hit Pav the same way and they go for 4 weeks, no doubt in the world.  Devalues the award when you see results like tonight.

[Smokey]

And I thought I was seeing things. Swan was on the verge of it and McGuire was thinking the same old - there all out to get collingwood poo.

We now all need to pray for a repeat of those looks from Eddie later this week!   

[TigerLand]

How much football does everyone watch?

He also missed 3 game playing 19. He is always going to be top 3 at Carltons every win.

No other player in the league influences his teams performance more than Chris Judd. Collingwood would be fine without Swan same with Geelong without Ablett.

Carlton without Judd are a bottom 6 side.

Judd nearly single handedly won the final against Sydney in the 2nd and 3rd qtr.

This happens every year, Kerr taking votes off Couins, Voss taking votes off Lappin, Grant and West taking votes off each other.