Brad Miller [merged]

[Jackstar is back again]

At least you know what you get with Brad
You dont know what lame effort you are going to get week to week with Vickery.
His smiling and carry on half time against Freo pretty well sums it up

[Judge Roughneck]

At least you know what you get with Brad

9 touches.
V Few goals. Very short kicking ability.
A turning circle of a boat and a defender that will rank up lots of easy ball and make jacks job tougher.

[WilliamPowell]

Just watched the replay - interesting indeed

No mention of his involvement in the Connors goal in the final qtr - mark, kick pass to Jackson who kicked it long tot he top of the square, Jack handballs it onto Connors

No mention of the shepherd he put on in the 3rd to allow Grigg to storm forward and kick 40+ metres into space for Edwards who over ran the ball

No mention of his tackle on Davis in the 3rd at the top of the goal square

No mention of his block for Nahas in the 2nd

These are just a few examples I've what I saw on the day that are a clear as a daylight on the replay but for whatever reasons seems to have been ingnored for convienience. 

People ask why he is in the side? The above (the 1 %ers) are a couple of reasons why he gets games.

[Judge Roughneck]

Go thou the game again and tell us the batchelor 1%ers / prec acts that you have not shared with us?

[Tigeritis™©®]

At least you know what you get with Brad

9 touches.
V Few goals. Very short kicking ability.
A turning circle of a boat and a defender that will rank up lots of easy ball and make jacks job tougher.

excellent Bents. Great post. 100% correct. 

[Tigeritis™©®]

At least you know what you get with Brad
You dont know what lame effort you are going to get week to week with Vickery.
His smiling and carry on half time against Freo pretty well sums it up

TV at 50% is already better than brad at 100%.

We all saw what he's capable of last year which is miles ahead of what brad can only dream of but don't let my opinion stop you from apologizing for calling me names. 

[Jackstar is back again]

Just watched the replay - interesting indeed

No mention of his involvement in the Connors goal in the final qtr - mark, kick pass to Jackson who kicked it long tot he top of the square, Jack handballs it onto Connors

No mention of the shepherd he put on in the 3rd to allow Grigg to storm forward and kick 40+ metres into space for Edwards who over ran the ball

No mention of his tackle on Davis in the 3rd at the top of the goal square

No mention of his block for Nahas in the 2nd

These are just a few examples I've what I saw on the day that are a clear as a daylight on the replay but for whatever reasons seems to have been ingnored for convienience. 

People ask why he is in the side? The above (the 1 %ers) are a couple of reasons why he gets games.

WP
It's pointless  discussing this with complete nuffers
If Vickery ever laid a block or a shepherd would be a first

[Jackstar is back again]

At least you know what you get with Brad
You dont know what lame effort you are going to get week to week with Vickery.
His smiling and carry on half time against Freo pretty well sums it up

TV at 50% is already better than brad at 100%.

We all saw what he's capable of last year which is miles ahead of what brad can only dream of but don't let my opinion stop you from apologizing for calling me names.

Do you actually watch and understand football ?
Vickery has never blocked for his team mates or laid a shepherd this year
Pointless me discussing any further with complete  idiots
Watch the game

[Judge Roughneck]

Vickery is worthy on his rucking alone. At which miller is horrid.

Let alone astbury elton post moore ohanlon

[gerkin greg]

Agree
Have watched Vickery's games twice and he does everything Miller does with the added bonus he can touch his toes and spoon feed his mids at ruck contests, and kick more than 30 metres
There's no point arguing with nuffers bentleigh

[Jackstar is back again]

Vickery is worthy on his rucking alone. At which miller is horrid.

Let alone astbury elton post moore ohanlon

You have no idea
Watch the Saints game
Vickery in ruck against Jason Blake of all people in last quarter and we got flogged in the middle for a 5 min period

[Jackstar is back again]

Agree
Have watched Vickery's games twice and he does everything Miller does with the added bonus he can touch his toes and spoon feed his mids at ruck contests, and kick more than 30 metres
There's no point arguing with nuffers bentleigh

Yep.no point .
Vickery in the last quarter against Jason Blake who ain't a ruckman and Vickery got flogged
Time to de activate my account
Way too many morons on here

[Judge Roughneck]

2012 vickery has six times as many hitouts to miller.

[Coach]

Jason Blake has played finals footy as a ruckman and almost got the Saints to a GF. Most underrated player in history and it is disgraceful that he's never had a Brownlow vote.

Most Miller has ever kicked in a season is 25. Jackstar's ex favourite Richmond player, Jay Schulz, has 29 from 8 games at a poo club. But no, let's talk up Miller and defend him 24/7. Seriously, what is the point of defending Miller by saying "well Vickery is worse"??? So what, neither of them have played well enough up forward. Vickery played one good game as a forward (this year) and Miller has contributed well in a couple too. Other than that they have both struggled. Vickery at least gives Maric a chop out in the ruck.

At the end of the day all this shows is that Miller isn't good enough and we need our young talls to come on quickly. We also need Vickery to get a move on.
Sick of arguing about Brad Miller. Nice bloke but what the stuff is he still going here? He must be sharing his wife with Dimma and the other coaches. This reminds me of the ol' days, debating about blokes like Tambo and Hughes

[Jackstar is back again]

please spare me, finals footy as a ruckman
Jason Blake has rarely played ruck FACT
Has been used down back .
5 years ago he was used a tagger on Judd.
pointless discussing with idiots