Favourite Player Game

[Hard Roar Tiger]

Well done Deledio lovers but Cotchin will be next year's favourite.

I don't mind that Cotchin was second, but it's all based on promise not actually delivering much yet

I promise you that he will deliver (if fit).

[Infamy]

Well done Deledio lovers but Cotchin will be next year's favourite.

I don't mind that Cotchin was second, but it's all based on promise not actually delivering much yet

I promise you that he will deliver (if fit).

I don't doubt that, however I still think it's ridiculous that a player that can't even run out a full game yet should be considered by so many as our favourite player.
He's had enough trouble just getting out on the park, if he can continue his development and turn into the player we think he will become then fine, but not yet, it's not deserved.

[tony_montana]

Well done Deledio lovers but Cotchin will be next year's favourite.

I don't mind that Cotchin was second, but it's all based on promise not actually delivering much yet

I promise you that he will deliver (if fit).

I don't doubt that, however I still think it's ridiculous that a player that can't even run out a full game yet should be considered by so many as our favourite player.
He's had enough trouble just getting out on the park, if he can continue his development and turn into the player we think he will become then fine, but not yet, it's not deserved.

well said

[Mr Magic]

I don't doubt that, however I still think it's ridiculous that a player that can't even run out a full game yet should be considered by so many as our favourite player.
He's had enough trouble just getting out on the park, if he can continue his development and turn into the player we think he will become then fine, but not yet, it's not deserved.

You might have a point Infamy if this thread was titled Proven Player Game.

[Infamy]

I don't doubt that, however I still think it's ridiculous that a player that can't even run out a full game yet should be considered by so many as our favourite player.
He's had enough trouble just getting out on the park, if he can continue his development and turn into the player we think he will become then fine, but not yet, it's not deserved.

You might have a point Infamy if this thread was titled Proven Player Game.

Sorry but I have a point anyway. How a kid who's done very little yet can be considered more popular than even our reigning Coleman medalist is a bit silly. Deledio at least has two Jack Dyer medals (almost three), two consecutive All Australian nominations and since Richo got injured has been our solo A grade player.

[Mr Magic]

How a kid who's done very little yet can be considered more popular than even our reigning Coleman medalist is a bit silly.

IYO. Cotchin has shown he's a top shelf mid in the making. Something Deledio has struggled to achieve to date. Trent also oozes leadership and will no doubt skipper our club.
Lids is a fine player no doubt but there's nothing at all silly about Cotchin being a fan favourite.

[gerkin greg]

What if your Coleman medalist was a wanker like Fraser Gehrig? Or your B&F winner was a prick like Nick Maxwell?

Favourite player doesn't have to have anything to do with talent, experience or achievements.

Thinking otherwise and having a meltdown about it is silly, stop being a gay sap Infamy.

[Smokey]

I don't doubt that, however I still think it's ridiculous that a player that can't even run out a full game yet should be considered by so many as our favourite player.
He's had enough trouble just getting out on the park, if he can continue his development and turn into the player we think he will become then fine, but not yet, it's not deserved.

You might have a point Infamy if this thread was titled Proven Player Game.

Yep.

[tiga]

I don't doubt that, however I still think it's ridiculous that a player that can't even run out a full game yet should be considered by so many as our favourite player.
He's had enough trouble just getting out on the park, if he can continue his development and turn into the player we think he will become then fine, but not yet, it's not deserved.

You might have a point Infamy if this thread was titled Proven Player Game.

Sorry but I have a point anyway. How a kid who's done very little yet can be considered more popular than even our reigning Coleman medalist is a bit silly. Deledio at least has two Jack Dyer medals (almost three), two consecutive All Australian nominations and since Richo got injured has been our solo A grade player.

The Spice Girls were popular too but that never made sense to me. As Magic said. Its not a proven player game. No individual can dictate the criteria for another persons method of favoritism.(unless you are Kim Jong-Il  ) Otherwise we might as well call it Infamy's favorite player game. So the point you make can only be relevant to yourself and anyone who chooses to agree with you. I still have Cotchin as my favorite player and you can make a thousand points in favour of Deledio, but as far as I'm concerned, my criteria for choosing Cotch as my favorite player remains unchanged.

[Penelope]

yeah, favorite player is the one you like to watch the most, not necessarily the best.

It's just a bit of offseason fluff/fun.

[Coach]

What if your Coleman medalist was a wanker like Fraser Gehrig? Or your B&F winner was a prick like Nick Maxwell?

Favourite player doesn't have to have anything to do with talent, experience or achievements.

Thinking otherwise and having a meltdown about it is silly, stop being a gay sap Infamy.

G Train is awesome.

[Hard Roar Tiger]

if this is the pre season standard, I can't wait for the regular season's banter.

[mightytiges]

Yeah Whitey I know it sucks losing. Lids won OER's favourite player game again!