Old Style Ramps Whose Gonna Make It List Update 2011

[10 FLAGS]

This is just my opinion of where the list is at. There is no right or wrong its just an opinion. Thats all!

2. Will Thursfield - Hasnt had a chance in 2011, I think hes in trouble list wise and could move in 2012.
3. Brett Deledio - 1 outstanding game 2 average ones in 2011. Another core key player for us long term.
4. Dustin Martin - 2nd year Blues who knows? Anyway, hes a long term player and part of our future.
6. Shaun Grigg - Been a good recruit so far. No complaints.
8. Jack Riewoldt - Outstanding 2010. Being targetted by media in 2011. Needs to just focus on footy.
9. Trent Cotchin - Outstanding player. Pity we dont have more.
10. Shane Edwards - Average start to 2011 after a good 2010. Needs to keep improving IMHO.
12. David Astbury - Average start to 2011 but we must perservere IMHO.
14. Bachar Houli - Been average for mine since he got here but who knows maybe he'll improve.
15. Mitchell Farmer - Where is he? Unseen in 2011.
16. Luke McGuane - Another one of our average Key Defenders. We need to find a quality one soon IMHO.
17. Chris Newman - Been a good captain and player.
18. Alex Rance - An enigma for mine. Needs to show something soon IMHO or hes in trouble.
19. Daniel Connors - I have concerns with Conners. No where near elite. Just an average player IMHO.
20. Mitch Morton - Gone backwards from last year! Whats happened to him playing on the wing.
21. Shane Tuck - Coming to the end IMHO but can reinvent as a high Half Forward going forward.
22. Ben Nason- Unseen in 2011. I reckon hes too small for AFL level footy.
23. Daniel Jackson -  Hacks the footy, average player with big commitment. Squad player in a successful team.
25. Angus Graham - No
26. Robin Nahas - Not for mine
28. Jake King - Well never been a fan, but hats off to him. He deserves every success. Hes worked for it.
29. Tyrone Vickery - Developing real well IMHO. Him and Derrickx offer a good potential ruck duo.
30. Reece Conca - Shows signs, should be a good player. Its time to put him on the wing.
31. Jake Batchelor - Like the early games of Batchelor. Should develop into a good player.
32. Brad Helbig - Yeah, I like Helbig, I think he can definately play and a player for the future.
33. David Gourdis - No
34. Andrew Browne- No
35. Matthew White - Never been a big fan. Just an average player in a very average team.
36. Dean MacDonald - To early to tell but exhibits good pace and could be ok of a HFF.
37. Jayden Post - Average player IMHO
38. Ben Griffiths - Injury prone but lots of potential and good for the structure of the side.
39. Tom Derickx - Like the early indications
40. Kelvin Moore - Good player
41. Nathan Foley - Needs more time now after injury. A Long way off the "Old Foley"
43. Matt Dea - Cant see him making it. Early indications were'nt good.
44. Troy Taylor - Has potential but hes not here now and hes a doubtful commodity long term.
46. Jeromey Webberley - Dime a dozen mid. No
48. Dylan Grimes - Like Grimes and think he has a future. Needs more game time.


Rookie List - (Maximum is 8 as we have no (outside) veterans. Minimum is 4).

13. Brad Miller - Not gonna be around after this year.
27. Tom Hislop - No
42. Jamie O'Reilly - I like O'Reilly, just dont know where his been this year.
45. Robert Hicks - Cant see Hicks making it
47. Ben Jakobi - Cant tell with Jakobi because I havent seen him play alot
49. Pat Contin - I like Contin but get the feeling he is a squad type player
51. Nick Westhoff - No

[WilliamPowell]

15. Mitchell Farmer - Where is he? Unseen in 2011.

Injured - severely bruised heel. Hoping to play for Coburg this week

42. Jamie O'Reilly - I like O'Reilly, just dont know where his been this year.

Injured as well been suffering shin splints

Will look at the rest tonight when I get home 

[Dubstep Dookie]

Ditto.

[red]

Who or what is "Ramps"?

[Oiafi]

"10 FLAGS" is the member formally known as "Ramps"

[jackstar is back again]

love the mitch morton summary

[Francois Jackson]

Ramps you are 100% spot on but willing to give Jackson another shot at it. King definately another contract IMO.

The only other one is Taylor. Why bother posting next to his game. Wasted draft selection. Good riddons thanks for nothing

These Nahas, Edwards and Nason types are not going to win us a flag. We need to face reality and quick

[TigerLand]

This is just my opinion of where the list is at. There is no right or wrong its just an opinion. Thats all!

2. Will Thursfield - Hasnt had a chance in 2011, I think hes in trouble list wise and could move in 2012.
3. Brett Deledio - 1 outstanding game 2 average ones in 2011. Another core key player for us long term.
4. Dustin Martin - 2nd year Blues who knows? Anyway, hes a long term player and part of our future.
6. Shaun Grigg - Been a good recruit so far. No complaints.
8. Jack Riewoldt - Outstanding 2010. Being targetted by media in 2011. Needs to just focus on footy.
9. Trent Cotchin - Outstanding player. Pity we dont have more.
10. Shane Edwards - Average start to 2011 after a good 2010. Needs to keep improving IMHO.
12. David Astbury - Average start to 2011 but we must perservere IMHO.
14. Bachar Houli - Been average for mine since he got here but who knows maybe he'll improve.
15. Mitchell Farmer - Where is he? Unseen in 2011.
16. Luke McGuane - Another one of our average Key Defenders. We need to find a quality one soon IMHO.
17. Chris Newman - Been a good captain and player.
18. Alex Rance - An enigma for mine. Needs to show something soon IMHO or hes in trouble.
19. Daniel Connors - I have concerns with Conners. No where near elite. Just an average player IMHO.
20. Mitch Morton - Gone backwards from last year! Whats happened to him playing on the wing.
21. Shane Tuck - Coming to the end IMHO but can reinvent as a high Half Forward going forward.
22. Ben Nason- Unseen in 2011. I reckon hes too small for AFL level footy.
23. Daniel Jackson -  Hacks the footy, average player with big commitment. Squad player in a successful team.
25. Angus Graham - No
26. Robin Nahas - Not for mine
28. Jake King - Well never been a fan, but hats off to him. He deserves every success. Hes worked for it.
29. Tyrone Vickery - Developing real well IMHO. Him and Derrickx offer a good potential ruck duo.
30. Reece Conca - Shows signs, should be a good player. Its time to put him on the wing.
31. Jake Batchelor - Like the early games of Batchelor. Should develop into a good player.
32. Brad Helbig - Yeah, I like Helbig, I think he can definately play and a player for the future.
33. David Gourdis - No
34. Andrew Browne- No
35. Matthew White - Never been a big fan. Just an average player in a very average team.
36. Dean MacDonald - To early to tell but exhibits good pace and could be ok of a HFF.
37. Jayden Post - Average player IMHO
38. Ben Griffiths - Injury prone but lots of potential and good for the structure of the side.
39. Tom Derickx - Like the early indications
40. Kelvin Moore - Good player
41. Nathan Foley - Needs more time now after injury. A Long way off the "Old Foley"
43. Matt Dea - Cant see him making it. Early indications were'nt good.
44. Troy Taylor - Has potential but hes not here now and hes a doubtful commodity long term.
46. Jeromey Webberley - Dime a dozen mid. No
48. Dylan Grimes - Like Grimes and think he has a future. Needs more game time.


Rookie List - (Maximum is 8 as we have no (outside) veterans. Minimum is 4).

13. Brad Miller - Not gonna be around after this year.
27. Tom Hislop - No
42. Jamie O'Reilly - I like O'Reilly, just dont know where his been this year.
45. Robert Hicks - Cant see Hicks making it
47. Ben Jakobi - Cant tell with Jakobi because I havent seen him play alot
49. Pat Contin - I like Contin but get the feeling he is a squad type player
51. Nick Westhoff - No

2. Will Thursfield - Gone
10. Shane Edwards - In Trouble, Trade Bait
16. Luke McGuane - Has currency, Trade Bait
18. Alex Rance - In Trouble, Trade Bait
20. Mitch Morton - Play on Wing.
21. Shane Tuck - Gone
25. Angus Graham - Gone
28. Jake King - May survive (Great endevour but wouldn't get a game in a top 4 side unfortunatly)
34. Andrew Browne - In Trouble
44. Troy Taylor - Unique case. Could reap the benfits if he returns but how long and how many chances do you give someone.

The rest will survive.

[1965]

Ramps you are 100% spot on but willing to give Jackson another shot at it. King definately another contract IMO.

The only other one is Taylor. Why bother posting next to his game. Wasted draft selection. Good riddons thanks for nothing

These Nahas, Edwards and Nason types are not going to win us a flag. We need to face reality and quick

Daniel mate buddy

Love your work but the word is riddance not riddons (again)

 

and "definitely" definitely does not have an "a" in it.

 

[mat073]

One bad loss and the forum turns into a blood thirsty witch hunt.

Nason -Played 17 games last year.Kicked more goals last year than Deledio,Cotchin and Cousins combined.At least Nason gets his hands dirty unlike a few of his prima donna team mates.

Matt Dea- talk about the sacrificial lamb.Played when we were being compared to Fitzroy...then got injured.

Webberley- Anyone remember the Hawthorn game last year when he put his body on the line.Averaged 15 disposals a game in 2010.Whats wrong with that ?

I do not see the point in blooding the kids, then taking the short term pain only to "write off " players after a handful of games.

[WilliamPowell]

One bad loss and the forum turns into a blood thirsty witch hunt.

mat073 it's just a bit of fun

And bloody funny I might add to have a look at one of these at season's end  

[10 FLAGS]

One bad loss and the forum turns into a blood thirsty witch hunt.

Nason -Played 17 games last year.Kicked more goals last year than Deledio,Cotchin and Cousins combined.At least Nason gets his hands dirty unlike a few of his prima donna team mates.

Matt Dea- talk about the sacrificial lamb.Played when we were being compared to Fitzroy...then got injured.

Webberley- Anyone remember the Hawthorn game last year when he put his body on the line.Averaged 15 disposals a game in 2010.Whats wrong with that ?

I do not see the point in blooding the kids, then taking the short term pain only to "write off " players after a handful of games.

The old style Ramps Updates were fantastic witch hunts. If you cant get a good witch hunt on OER where do you think your gonna get one? 

[Mr Magic]

Good thread. Early days but this is what I see unfolding..

Thursfield - Delist.
Tuck - Delist.
Gourdis - Delist.
Taylor - Delist.
Post - Delist.
Two of Webberley, Nason, Farmer or Dea to be delisted. - Decision to be made.

Miller - Delist
Hislop - Delist
Westhoff - Delist
Hicks - Decision to be made.
Contin - Decision to be made.
O'Reilly - Decision to be made.


Edwards - Possible trade bait.
Connors - Possible trade bait.
Morton - Possible trade bait.
Graham - Possible trade bait.
Moore or Rance - Possible trade bait.
White - Possible trade bait.

McGuane - Required player for another season.

[Stripes]

Good thread. Early days but this is what I see unfolding..

Thursfield - Delist.
Tuck - Delist.
Gourdis - Delist.
Taylor - Delist.
Post - Delist.
Two of Webberley, Nason, Farmer or Dea to be delisted. - Decision to be made.

Miller - Delist
Hislop - Delist
Westhoff - Delist
Hicks - Decision to be made.
Contin - Decision to be made.
O'Reilly - Decision to be made.


Edwards - Possible trade bait.
Connors - Possible trade bait.
Morton - Possible trade bait.
Graham - Possible trade bait.
Moore or Rance - Possible trade bait.
White - Possible trade bait.

McGuane - Required player for another season.

19 players gone in one season, particularly when GWS will be rodging the buggery out of the draft, may be a little harsh MM. Even if you just follow your 'delists' that would be 8 which would be too many for mine unless we want to get rid of average players only to replay them with average to poor players.

[Mr Magic]

19 players gone in one season

I have absolutely no idea how you came to that conclusion.

Even if you just follow your 'delists' that would be 8 which would be too many for mine

It's only 7 delisted off the main list which isn't cutting all that deep at all for a team that's still well off the pace.