Geisch gives the okay to decisions against Newy and Rance

[one-eyed]

According to Geisch:

Newy pinged for looking back and that's classed as a block. Even if you hold your ground if you look back then it's classed as your intent is on the player and not the ball.

Rance pinged for holding Stefan Martin's right arm down. The vision is on the wrong side to see it (ump was in a position to see it).


Vision starts at 4.00min
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/117300/default.aspx

[tiga]

If thats the case with Rance then it should have been play on considering they were holding each other.

[Dubstep Dookie]

This just in, Geisha gives the ok for the 1993 Rwandan Genocides.

[Tigermonk]

If thats the case with Rance then it should have been play on considering they were holding each other.

yeah but it was against Richmond so the decision always goes to the other team

its disgraceful the umpiring over the last 10 years

[wayne]

Newy wasn't far from the ball, what would have happened if he marked it?

[Tigermonk]

Newy wasn't far from the ball, what would have happened if he marked it?

whats wrong with todays football is they taking the contest out of it. Every player looks back to view his opponant before the contest.
football is in full damage mode by Demetriou, Anderson, Fitzpatrick, Geishien. & several umpires can go with them.

[Owl]

Well plow me sideways with a morning star.  This genetically challenged troglodyte looking prick just takes the cake doesn't he?  Does he think he is stuffing Luke Skywalker pulling some bullsh!t Jedi mind trick on us or something?  Newman tackled him without the ball with his powerful gaze...  And, Rance used the other players arm to tackle himself or something... now I have stuffing heard it all, pardon me while I finishing feeding my unicorn.  If Geischen is run over by a truck, I will consider it a boon to our game.

[The Big Richo]

If thats the case with Rance then it should have been play on considering they were holding each other.

yeah but it was against Richmond so the decision always goes to the other team

its disgraceful the umpiring over the last 10 years

TM are you seriously suggesting that the umpires deliberately favour Richmond's opponents?

[Tigermonk]

TM are you seriously suggesting that the umpires deliberately favour Richmond's opponents?

Yes thats correct l do. l see some deplorable decisions by umpires against Richmond for many years. But the same umpires having clear view & in the correct position call many times the wrong decision for the same incident. We always get raped at the tribunal as well for years


Just to sum this up, was watching Greg Williams ( former VFL/AFL Brownlow Medalist) talking in a interview last night. he clearly said umpires were against him & l beleive there are 2 in the system now that hate Richmond. l know Fact that Geishein hates Richmond & have heard it come from his own mouth.

[WilliamPowell]

If thats the case with Rance then it should have been play on considering they were holding each other.

Correct

it was a shocker

[smasha]

Both were 50/50's and if umpires had any semblance of common sense ,they would be play on calls.

Both 50/50's in front of goal I see.

And to put the cherry on the cake King got a week for stuff all.

[Dubstep Dookie]

Which site member posted the umps 'restore the natural balance' post? Twas about 3-4 weeks ago.

Very appropriate here (and kudos to them).

[mightytiges]

The ump and Geisch conveniently ignored Stephan Martin's left arm being over Rance's shoulder  .

[Smokey]

Well plow me sideways with a morning star.  This genetically challenged troglodyte looking prick just takes the cake doesn't he?  Does he think he is effing Luke Skywalker pulling some bullpoo Jedi mind trick on us or something?  Newman tackled him without the ball with his powerful gaze...  And, Rance used the other players arm to tackle himself or something... now I have effing heard it all, pardon me while I finishing feeding my unicorn.  If Geischen is run over by a truck, I will consider it a boon to our game.

 

[Hellenic Tiger]

Too bad Dr Jack Kevorkian passed away recently........