Tigers vs Crows game thread

[Muscles]

Great game, good feeling pity it wasn't with something on the line.
All this talk about deslisting /trading is great stuff.
 
Is Newman untouchable?

In reality he would get us more than he is going to give. If we are going to be tough at the trade table would we trade Newman for Butcher?

Which was the last team to trade a current captain?

[MintOnLamb]

Don't know, Ball was a past captain (1 year??)

[tony_montana]

Great game, good feeling pity it wasn't with something on the line.
All this talk about deslisting /trading is great stuff.
 
Is Newman untouchable?

In reality he would get us more than he is going to give. If we are going to be tough at the trade table would we trade Newman for Butcher?

us i think
Which was the last team to trade a current captain?

[one-eyed]

Gieschen's "What's you decision?" video is up on the AFL website..

Rance pinged for deliberate rushed behind:
Giesch said Rance's intent despite fumbling was to get the ball across the line and so it's deliberate. They are going to be tough on this now. Giesch claimed that Rance wouldn't have fumbled the ball if he was a forward running into goal.

Cotch 'non-mark' which Adelaide got a goal out of
That was a mistake and Cotch should have received a free. Cotch took the mark and then had his arm chopped. Giesch said initially Van Berlo's fist wasn't far from the ball ???.

[Penelope]

Geishan has one of those big bendy straws.

He uses it to felch himself.

[Coach]

You are a sick man al

I do hate the Geish

[mightytiges]

Gieschen's "What's you decision?" video is up on the AFL website..

Rance pinged for deliberate rushed behind:
Giesch said Rance's intent despite fumbling was to get the ball across the line and so it's deliberate. They are going to be tough on this now. Giesch claimed that Rance wouldn't have fumbled the ball if he was a forward running into goal.

That's why Dusty fumbled the ball running into an open goal and almost stuffed it up hey Geisch    .

Seems Geisch now expects umps to be mind readers .

[WilliamPowell]

And so what the explanation regarding Johncock's deliberate smacking the ball over the boundary line then? He fumbled it 

[wayne]

Kanga coach Scott was on AFL Insider before and said to keep the rule simple and what it was meant for. To stop what happened in the 2008 grand final. Anything other than than is ok. 

[Ox]

What about Johncock?



Edited: gutter talk 

[mightytiges]

And so what the explanation regarding Johncock's deliberate smacking the ball over the boundary line then? He fumbled it 

That's not a Richmond player so that's okay . Ziebell's was the worst. He punched the ball from 15m out for a point facing the play and with no one around him yet that wasn't called deliberate (Giesch admitted at least it should have been a free).

As for Rance's, now Giesch expects the umps to be mindreaders  .

[WilliamPowell]

Ziebell's was the worst. He punched the ball from 15m out for a point facing the play and with no one around him yet that wasn't called deliberate (Giesch admitted at least it should have been a free).

No no Ziebell was under pressure...he plays for N0rt now that's gotta be constant mental pressure to play for that joke of a club and live up to the old "shinboner spirit"

[mightytiges]

No no Ziebell was under pressure...he plays for N0rt now that's gotta be constant mental pressure to play for that joke of a club and live up to the old "shinboner spirit"

Shinboner spirit is being in front by 20 and then losing by 70  .

[Hellenic Tiger]

Ziebell's was the worst. He punched the ball from 15m out for a point facing the play and with no one around him yet that wasn't called deliberate (Giesch admitted at least it should have been a free).

No no Ziebell was under pressure...he plays for N0rt now that's gotta be constant mental pressure to play for that joke of a club and live up to the old "shinboner spirit"

Totally agree WP.

Useless fanless characterless penniless nothingness footy club.

[Owl]

And don't forget they voted us to be kicked out the comp when we were down, lets kick the living crapier out of em I say and help them down into the pits of despair so we get to return the favor.