Miller Time (Herald-Sun)

[Penelope]

Bingo Jackie boy.

That is why what the club achieved on field this year gets a pass mark. When you take into account the state of the list we have done OK.

As for delisting 20, how the eff do you replace them. Use picks 70 -90?

LMFAO

[TigerTimeII]

you already know they cant play.
We dont have a magic wand to wave and turn them into champions.

u said last yr rance couldnt play, even quite a few times this yr lol

[Jackstar is back again]

Rance has improved but had too, whats the big deal.
If he didnt improve he would be out the door,.

[Francois Jackson]

you already know they cant play.
We dont have a magic wand to wave and turn them into champions.

u said last yr rance couldnt play, even quite a few times this yr lol

you also said Dimma wouldnt let Tambling go and your mates with Conca.
I think IIRC you claimed he "had a role to play in the team"


Edited: keep the name calling and personal insults off the forum. Dont' agree argue the point - it isn't that hard

[Jackstar is back again]

Bingo Jackie boy.

That is why what the club achieved on field this year gets a pass mark. When you take into account the state of the list we have done OK.

As for delisting 20, how the eff do you replace them. Use picks 70 -90?

LMFAO

Would delist or trade the following., as  the following wont win you finals

Farmer,
Morton
Tuck.
Nason
Jackson
Graham
King
Hislop
Gourdis
White
Connors
Hicks
Westoff
Browne.
Miller
Dea
O,Reilly
McGaune
Derrickx ( too injury prone)
Edwards
Astbury.

There is 21 !
Will never ever play finals footy

[WilliamPowell]

Derrickx ( too injury prone)

How can a bloke who breaks an ankle when an opponent crashes into to him be deemed "injury prone" 

[Jackstar is back again]

Derrickx ( too injury prone)

How can a bloke who breaks an ankle when an opponent crashes into to him be deemed "injury prone" 

past history says so
also playing 2nds at Claremont in 2009 is hardly a good grounding.
.Would be like playing 2nds at Coburg.
I actually like him , although his resume is hardly one that you would ""go off"' over

[Penelope]

past history?
LMAO

when did he last have a broken ankle due to an opponent falling on him?

He really only started taking footy seriously a few years ago, but in those three or so years , despite being injury prone, he has found himself at an AFL Club?

WOW, what an effort!

I notice once again you didn't answer the previous question?

[Coach]

Guys, just pop into Beefcakes thread and be positive. K?

[Jackstar is back again]

past history?
LMAO

when did he last have a broken ankle due to an opponent falling on him?

He really only started taking footy seriously a few years ago, but in those three or so years , despite being injury prone, he has found himself at an AFL Club?

WOW, what an effort!

I notice once again you didn't answer the previous question?

Yep Relton Roberts found himself at an AFL Club too, big deal.
Mate played with him at Claremont in 2009, hardly set the world on fire.
Got near the ball twice in a NAB game and people here go off, LOL
Before you comment again Al, find out how many injuries this player has  had,
Include Margaret River Football Club and Claremont seconds please

[TigerTimeII]

Rance has improved but had too, whats the big deal.
If he didnt improve he would be out the door,.

so maybe some players that u think are duds still have a chance to improve

[WilliamPowell]

Guys, just pop into Beefcakes thread and be positive. K?

I can't I am banned

[Jackstar is back again]

Rance has improved but had too, whats the big deal.
If he didnt improve he would be out the door,.

so maybe some players that u think are duds still have a chance to improve

Wouldnt think there are any better than average AFL players in my list of 21 above

[Penelope]

past history?
LMAO

when did he last have a broken ankle due to an opponent falling on him?

He really only started taking footy seriously a few years ago, but in those three or so years , despite being injury prone, he has found himself at an AFL Club?

WOW, what an effort!

I notice once again you didn't answer the previous question?

Yep Relton Roberts found himself at an AFL Club too, big deal.
Mate played with him at Claremont in 2009, hardly set the world on fire.
Got near the ball twice in a NAB game and people here go off, LOL
Before you comment again Al, find out how many injuries this player has  had,
Include Margaret River Football Club and Claremont seconds please

WTF has that got to do with anything?


you made the statement he is injury prone.

what is his history of being injury prone? when was it ?at margaret river? three years ago?

so a bloke who goes through two seasons with out any significant injury and is then injured by another player is injury prone?

Why do you feel a need to make poo up just to bag the club and slander the players?

[WilliamPowell]

Wouldnt think there are any better than average AFL players in my list of 21 above

Just on 2 of them I reckon you're being incredibly harsh

Astbury - only his 2nd season and he has missed more than half the season with a dislocated kneecap and you think he should be de-listed - huge room for improvement in him IMHO

O'Reilly - again 2nd season in game that he to a degree is still learning...please ...if we applied your criteria on the like Keneally at the Swans he'd never played in a premiership

DerrickX - 1 season - deserves a chance to see if he can play

Also you are suggesting we get rid of all our ruckmen in one hit - we have enough problems in that area without willingly creating more...who do you replace them with