So who do you leave out of Rd1 after NAB3?

[tiga]

Conc's is a cert. I'd say Helbig will be the casualty. Its been a long time since we have been able to say who will be left out.  I like it much better than having to sift through Coburg's list to see who will we have to elevate to replace duds.

[10 FLAGS]

Deledio has missed alot of footy I would have him as sub in R1 and bring him on with 10 minutes to go in the 3rd quarter.

[MADTIGER2010]

In-deledio, conca
Out-king, tuck

[Dubstep Dookie]

In-deledio, conca
Out-king, tuck

Tuck out?

[Phil Mrakov]

I'd like to have Stevie Morris on standby as a sub just incase Betts and Garlett run riot .

I reckon he'd be one of the few that could take em on.

[Fluffy Tiger]

Ins:- Deledio, Conca
Outs:- King, Helbig.

Agree with this, but wait guys we have week to go so things could change. One would hope lots of kids get a go next week against GWS and some of the more important cogs get a week off. Except lids ofcourse who needs the game time.

[MADTIGER2010]

In-deledio, conca
Out-king, tuck

Tuck out?

Still makes the same old kicking errors and takes a lifetime to move the ball on in traffic. I'm sure we'll be seeing the usual mistakes in Round 1 if he plays

[WilliamPowell]

Interesting views I couldn't decide who to leave out for Conca, though I was throwing up Nahas who's been (IMO) only OK in the last couple of games.

But certainly Helbig would be the one if you are talking "like for like"

[Willy]

Nahas' previous two NAB games where underwhelming by his standards. I thought he looked very dangerous and sharp against the cats tho. Offers a lot more than Helbig at this stage.

In: Conca, Lids
Out: Helbig, King

[tigtuff12]

agree with most so far - Helbig & Kingy for Lids and Concs...

Tucky def still has same deficiencies but I think the hard body/tough in contests will hold him in good stead for round 1...it'll obviously be fierce in the middle and I think he will help take some of the heat and sting out of it for our young onball brigade...

[Coach]

Interesting views I couldn't decide who to leave out for Conca, though I was throwing up Nahas who's been (IMO) only OK in the last couple of games.

But certainly Helbig would be the one if you are talking "like for like"

Lucky Nahas posts on another forum and not this one, WP.

[DCrane]

Nahas' previous two NAB games where underwhelming by his standards. I thought he looked very dangerous and sharp against the cats tho. Offers a lot more than Helbig at this stage.

When Kingy comes back, it looks like he will be fighting for either Nahas' or Mini Maric's spot. Helbig would need an injury to happen to someone else to get a game imo. If he was going to accidentally knock someone out at training, he would be better off cleaning up Bachelor or Houli.

[Hellenic Tiger]

Addam Maric or Conca will be sub?
Tucky sub ?

The more I think about it the sub will be either Maric or Nahas. Probably Maric and he'll probably be subbed in for either Nahas if he's having a stinker or Tuck depending on how the mids are performing.

[gerkin greg]

not a bad call tucker

[Willy]

What about Lids? Is he a possible candidate for the sub?
Will he be fit enough to run out a full modern game?