MRP watch

[Penelope]

Buddy grabs Johncock by the leg. Free kick paid for the trip.
Commentators then ask whether he's in trouble and all say they don't want to see Buddy suspended. 

So not only does Buddy (and a few other pets like Judd) get the rub of the umpiring - note the holding Talia's arm with one hand and pushing in the back with the other - but they also operate to a different set of rules at the MRP.

pretty sure tripping is only reportable if by done by foot.

[dwaino]

I kept watching the footage of the scuffle over and over, and unless there's any better video somewhere else I can't see Maric getting done unless Davey gets done too. The footage is flimsy, but the footage of Davey is clear as day.

[RedanTiger]

pretty sure tripping is only reportable if by done by foot.

Very sure that it's reportable by hand as well.
They jumped in a few years ago when they realised the damage that could be caused by any type of trip.
Imagine if Johncock had damaged his ankle/knee while Buddy was holding and twisting.

Obvious though that they Anderson will find some way to get him off if you go by Judd splitting Pavlich's face open with an elbow.

[Go Richo 12]

What's Rance's history with the MRP like?

has points - suspended round 1 last year for a late hit on some Carlton player. 2-3 games for memory

Was that Rance or McGaune? Or was McGaune a victim?

[Penelope]

pretty sure tripping is only reportable if by done by foot.

Very sure that it's reportable by hand as well.
They jumped in a few years ago when they realised the damage that could be caused by any type of trip.
Imagine if Johncock had damaged his ankle/knee while Buddy was holding and twisting.

Obvious though that they Anderson will find some way to get him off if you go by Judd splitting Pavlich's face open with an elbow.

they may have changed it, but it was only by foot.
by hand has grey areas as to whether it is deliberate ( not buddys' though), tripping by leg is straight forward.

we'll find out in the next 24 hours

[WilliamPowell]

What's Rance's history with the MRP like?

has points - suspended round 1 last year for a late hit on some Carlton player. 2-3 games for memory

Was that Rance or McGaune? Or was McGaune a victim?

MCGuane was the victim - kicked in the ...errr....ummmm..NUTs by that sniper waite who got off

Same game Rance got reported

McGuane got reported in round 2 -v- the Saints

[WA Tiger]

What's Rance's history with the MRP like?

has points - suspended round 1 last year for a late hit on some Carlton player. 2-3 games for memory

Hmmm. Not good. We really cant afford to lose him.

Willy, we can't afford to lose the cleaner at the club house at the moment mate, honestly, this goes to show that we really don't have the depth. This has been one of our biggest problems over theses and continues to affect us.

We just can't lose anyone.

[Willy]

What's Rance's history with the MRP like?

has points - suspended round 1 last year for a late hit on some Carlton player. 2-3 games for memory

Hmmm. Not good. We really cant afford to lose him.

Willy, we can't afford to lose the cleaner at the club house at the moment mate, honestly, this goes to show that we really don't have the depth. This has been one of our biggest problems over theses and continues to affect us.

We just can't lose anyone.

I agree with you WAT. Our depth is still weak, but some of our players are more expendable than others. We could afford a Jackson an Edwards, or even a Newman to go down, but Rance is critical 1. because he's blossomed into a consistent performer 2. because his potential replacements are either injured or poo.

[WA Tiger]

What's Rance's history with the MRP like?

has points - suspended round 1 last year for a late hit on some Carlton player. 2-3 games for memory

Willy, we can't afford to lose the cleaner at the club house at the moment mate, honestly, this goes to show that we really don't have the depth. This has been one of our biggest problems over theses and continues to affect us.

We just can't lose anyone.

I agree with you WAT. Our depth is still weak, but some of our players are more expendable than others. We could afford a Jackson an Edwards, or even a Newman to go down, but Rance is critical 1. because he's blossomed into a consistent performer 2. because his potential replacements are either injured or poo.

Yep dead right mate!! Going in againt the Cats, we really can't afford to lose him!

[Coach]

Looks like McGuane might get another crack

[Willy]

Looks like McGuane might get another crack

you reckon Rance will go, uncle?

[Coach]

Looks like McGuane might get another crack

you reckon Rance will go, uncle?

Dunno young fella. Didn't even see what you guys are talking about But McGawn may get a chance with Geelong playing 3 tall forwards. Pods, Hawkins and West will be resting there. We'll need another big body I'd say

[Willy]

Looks like McGuane might get another crack

you reckon Rance will go, uncle?

Dunno young fella. Didn't even see what you guys are talking about But McGawn may get a chance with Geelong playing 3 tall forwards. Pods, Hawkins and West will be resting there. We'll need another big body I'd say

could have Post and Maguane in the side!   

[Coach]

Times like these Will Thursfield would be handy

[Willy]

Thursty's gone fishin.