MRP watch

[tony_montana]

What's Rance's history with the MRP like?

has points - suspended round 1 last year for a late hit on some Carlton player. 2-3 games for memory

for mine that was a joke of a suspension and was similar to the whitecross incident with J.Selwood, Waite turned blind straight back into Rance, all Rance did was hold his ground, he didnt bump him, was he meant to move out of the way and allow Waite to run free, was a joke of a suspension.

and are they serious that they might look at Rances late spoil on Watts? LOL!!! that was a SOFT pat, barely connected

[Coach]

you're wrong. watch it again (Waite incident)

[tony_montana]

you're wrong. watch it again (Waite incident)

wrong in what way?

i remember it clearly, he stood his ground

tell me what u saw differently

[Coach]

There is a difference bewteen standing your ground and knocking someone on their ass when they can't even see you. Deserved to be reported

[tony_montana]

fair enough your call, i saw it differently, i didnt see it as Rance trying to knocking him down, I saw him stand his ground and Waite ran straight into his shoulder. If he tried to bump him even slightly then Id say fair enough, but for mine I didnt think he did.

[Coach]

some vision of the incident would be handy. it was a year ago after all

[Tigermonk]

expect Richmond to be raped again this week by the Geishiens

[Go Richo 12]

What's Rance's history with the MRP like?

has points - suspended round 1 last year for a late hit on some Carlton player. 2-3 games for memory

Was that Rance or McGaune? Or was McGaune a victim?

MCGuane was the victim - kicked in the ...errr....ummmm..NUTs by that sniper waite who got off

Same game Rance got reported

McGuane got reported in round 2 -v- the Saints

Yup thats right, memory coming back now! Thanks

[Francois Jackson]

All clear

[WilliamPowell]

yep all clear

From the Afl site:

Richmond's Ivan Maric has escaped penalty, despite appearing to strike Melbourne's Jordie McKenzie. The Match Review Panel ruled the contact was with an open hand and lacked the force to be reportable.

Full article: http://www.afl.com.au/News/NEWSARTICLE/tabid/208/newsId/133228/Default.aspx

[Smokey]

I can't believe Davey got off for the jumper punches he threw or the ones lying on the ground in the melee.

[JVT]

I can't believe Davey got off for the jumper punches he threw or the ones lying on the ground in the melee.

Not only did he get off, didn't get a mention . . . 

[WA Tiger]

Thank God for this news!!!!!

[Dubstep Dookie]

Thank God for this news!!!!!

Agreed. Imagine if the big papillion was our frontline ruckman against the cats? Orrenson would tear him a new VaJayjay

[Tigermonk]

thats great lets get the Geelong game on