Lloyd's coach rankings - Hardwick listed 5th best in AFL

[one-eyed]

Matty Lloyd on 3aw tonight was asked by BT and Russell to list the coaches from best to worst in the AFL. He put Hardwick as 5th best.

1. Sanderson (Adel)
2. Buckley (Coll)
3. Worsfold (WC)
4. Hird (Ess)
5. Hardwick (Rich)
6. Watters (St K)
7. Sheedy/Williams (GWS)
8. Longmire (Syd)
9. Primus (Port)
10. Chris Scott (Geel)
11. McCartney (Dogs)
12. Clarkson (Haw)
13. Voss (Bris)
14. Ratten (Carl)
15. Lyon (Freo)
16. Brad Scott (North)
17. Neeld (Melb)
18. McKenna (GC)

nb. the criteria was judging performance so far this year with the quality of the playing list each coach had to work with.

[Damo]

Sheedy/Williams have done as AMAZING job. They are too low

[TigerTimeII]

lloyd is a toss

buckley is by far on top with injuries they have had
dimma second with the draw we have had
hird no way, bombers have had the easiest draw til now, lets see where they ar eat in 6 weeks hey
watters is 3rd
primus 4th with what he has to work with

cant rate worsefold as he has 3 extra players om the field every minute for him, cheats

[bojangles17]

The bulldogs form has been grossly overrated, apart from wins against likely bottom 4 they have been thrashed ea time

[gerkin greg]

if Lloyd is peddling Sheedy/Williams then his list should also read Hird/Thompson

[smasha]

if Lloyd is peddling Sheedy/Williams then his list should also read Hird/Thompson

Which would push them down the list more.

[Tiger Woods]

I think we got the better ex-bomber IMO.

I have dubbed him "No Doubt" Dimma.

If I lined up every media conference he has been in and had a shot every time he says " there's no doubt about that", I'd be dead by round 15

No Doubt he will take us to the promised land 

[rogerd3]

Hird doesnt coach, please.

[gerkin greg]

He's a coke rag.

[tiger101]

Surprised he didn't put Hird first.

[Phil Mrakov]

We will finish above Essendon.

[Damo]

We will finish above Essendon.

Don't think we will. They are 3 games and % clear with a decent draw.

We will play finals though, and from there anything can happen.

[Judge Roughneck]

Essendon will come unstuck. One of the least talented lists imo

[Damo]

Essendon will come unstuck. One of the least talented lists imo

Hope so