Half way mark. Who is top 10 B&F

[Bengal]

my top 10 in no particular order would be

Tuck
Lids
Cotch
Rance
Edwards
Conca
Foley
IVAN
Dusty
Morris

[jordie2tivendale]

I m biased but  ffs ivan  would be top 3 atm  by a long long way

[Bengal]

I m biased but  ffs ivan  would be top 3 atm  by a long long way

oops 

[Coach]

not sure Dusty would be polling that well

[one-eyed]

According to the AFL Coaches votes up to round 12:

Cotchin   54
Deledio   37
I.Maric    29
Tuck      23
Foley     13
Grigg     13
Riewoldt 11
Rance    10
Grimes    9
Edwards  6
---------------
Martin     4
Conca     4
Nahas     3
Houli       1
Newman  1

http://aflca.com.au/index.php?id=8

[gerkin greg]

Chimp
Lids
Ivan
Tuck
Grigg
Tross
Foley
Grimeball
Morris
Jack

[Ruanaidh]

According to the AFL Coaches votes up to round 12:

Cotchin   54
Deledio   37
I.Maric    29
Tuck      23
Foley     13
Grigg     13
Riewoldt 11
Rance    10
Grimes    9
Edwards  6
---------------
Martin     4
Conca     4
Nahas     3
Houli       1
Newman  1

http://aflca.com.au/index.php?id=8

Can't argue with that

[WA Tiger]

my top 10 in no particular order would be

Tuck
Lids
Cotch
Rance
Edwards
Conca
Foley
IVAN
Dusty
Morris

Grigg is playing all over Martin at the minute....and you left him off??? He is also playing better than Rance and Morris, while they are still traveling ok.

[Mr Magic]

Dusty's been disappointing to date. So has Vickery obviously.

[mightytiges]

1. Cotch
2. Lids
3. Ivan
4. Rance
5. Grigg
6. Foley
7. Tuck
8. Morris
9. Jack
10. Edwards

Grimes would be in the top 10 if he hadn't missed the past month of footy.

[TigerLand]

Chimp
Lids
Ivan
Tuck
Grigg
Tross
Foley
Grimeball
Morris
Jack

Agree

[the claw]

dunno about top 10 but top 5 for me would go.
maric.
cotchin.
deledio
morris
grigg/tuck

[Fluffy Tiger]

1. Cotch
2. Lids
3. Ivan
4. Rance
5. Grigg
6. Foley
7. Tuck
8. Morris
9. Jack
10. Edwards

Grimes would be in the top 10 if he hadn't missed the past month of footy.

Top 8 of those have been fairly consistant. The other 2 are a in there by default atm I would say.  Cant think of 2 others to definatly replace them with though.

[mightytiges]

1. Cotch
2. Lids
3. Ivan
4. Rance
5. Grigg
6. Foley
7. Tuck
8. Morris
9. Jack
10. Edwards

Grimes would be in the top 10 if he hadn't missed the past month of footy.

Top 8 of those have been fairly consistant. The other 2 are a in there by default atm I would say.  Cant think of 2 others to definatly replace them with though.

Yep Fluffy,  the last two places aren't certainties. Of those left out Grimes has missed a month as I said; Dusty has been down this year especially his goalkicking; Newy has had a couple of beauties but been so-so in the rest; same with Houli; Nahas is up and down like a yo-yo - his best can be match-turning but he goes missing at his worse; Kingy is suspended half the time; Jacko is ... well Jacko; and there's not really anyone else to consider top 20 material from the rest. Conca has improved but not to the level you'd have him in the yop 10 of the B&F IMHO.

[Judge Roughneck]

Tell him hes dreaming

Rance > grigg

my top 10 in no particular order would be

Tuck
Lids
Cotch
Rance
Edwards
Conca
Foley
IVAN
Dusty
Morris

Grigg is playing all over Martin at the minute....and you left him off??? He is also playing better than Rance and Morris, while they are still traveling ok.