Brent Moloney

[tony_montana]

Sylvia

yep

[tigs2011]

Id be more interested in sylvia, either free agent or package up connors with a 3 rounder

Of all the trade a spud and a poo pick this has to take the cake. 

[Smokey]

Sylvia would go down in our history as a worse trade than Kingsley.  Absolute unreliable dud who only ever plays 1-2 half decent games a year - both against us unfortunately.   

[Coach]

Sylvia would go down in our history as a worse trade than Kingsley.  Absolute unreliable dud who only ever plays 1-2 half decent games a year - both against us unfortunately.   

We didn't trade for Kingsley. Sylvia can play. He can be an absolute weapon on his day. Not sure I want us to take a punt on him though

[eliminator]

Caddy-yes. Moloney too old

[the claw]

Caddy-yes. Moloney too old

caddy yes moloney yes.mature state league mid yes. 2nd rounder mid  yes.  compensation pick mid yes.. thats 5 genuine mids right there and an immediate improvement in mid field depth both in the long term and short term.
it also leaves us with two reasonable nd picks in pick 50ish 68ish plus a free agency option and rookie selections.

[tony_montana]

Sylvia would go down in our history as a worse trade than Kingsley.  Absolute unreliable dud who only ever plays 1-2 half decent games a year - both against us unfortunately.   

If we could get him via pre season draft, Id jump at it. Can absolutely tear teams apart when on. Problem is he has only shown it in sporadic patches but I'd take a punt on a player that would potentially bolster our matchwinners stocks. Wouldnt give up any of our first 3 picks though

[the claw]

hmm lets see here. its okay to take a what 28 yo next yr in sylvia a player who is so inonsistant its not funny but its not alright to take 29 yo next yr who is hard at it  consistent   and add depth to an area we badly lack in.

we are talking late nd or psd picks here i hope when we talk about maybe getting either of them.
thing is sylvia wont go anywhere and moloney is as good as out the door .

i dont get this too old age thing.  they are only too old if you have no kids in your system. last time i looked we have more kids than most and could really do with some more older types to show the way and add some ready made depth to an area thats lacking it. even if they are only there for two or three yrs.

 the only criteria is age you aint going to give up good picks for 28 or 29 yr olds.

[tony_montana]

Maloney will be 29 in January and 29 throughout the 2013 campaign

Sylvia is still 26 and will turn 27 in the off season, will be 27 throughout the entire 2013 campaign

 dunno why you are trying to make it out as if its the same thing, 2 years is a bit of a difference

[Tigeritis™©®]

Chris knights.

Struggling to get a decent run of games at Adelaide and he's a Victorian.

A  mid / forward with muscles. 

he'd be cheap too.   

[Loui Tufga]

Chris knights.

Struggling to get a decent run of games at Adelaide and he's a Victorian.

A  mid / forward with muscles. 

he'd be cheap too.

He would want o be cheap to, has pee poor disposal. Would give him the benefit of the doubt because of his bad run of injury that he can improove on it but with is injury history and his disposal he would be a big risk IMO.

[DCrane]

the only criteria is age you aint going to give up good picks for 28 or 29 yr olds.

With the introduction of free agency, we should not have to give up any picks at all for a 28/29 yo, most of them should be unrestricted free agents by that age.

We have an age gap on our list that Sylvia could assist with but he is terribly unreliable and I can't see that changing. Moloney is second rate, rookie list spot and rookie list wages at best on him.

[Judge Roughneck]

No colin. No.

[mightytiges]

Too old now for us but we could have had Moloney as part of the Ottens trade back in 2004. Geelong originally offered us their first pick (#16) plus Moloney. Greg Miller wanted two first rounders so Geelong traded Moloney to Melbourne in exchange for one of their two back-to-back first rounders (#12) which was passed onto us. Melbourne drafted Bate with their other first rounder and we of course drafted Meyer and Pattison  .

[tigs2011]

Go the NBA route and try pick up cheap veterans?

Would rather Moloney than Sylvia.

I agree with Santa that we need to pick up some mature agers from state leagues this year in particular a decent KPF.