2012 Richmond Delistings [merged]

[Coach]

One was a kid who became a #1 ruck at a young age

For a club with no other ruckman, although people rooting for him won't admit it

There was 200 game veteran Troy Simmonds. And Browne was here which slaps your point for 6 considering it was a comparison between the two

[Phil Mrakov]

Wow must have been in hot form. LMFAO lets bring him back via the rookie list

Agree Coach.  I think there is still some upside to BrownE - he has shown glimpses that might be worth persevering with, especially if he's only on the rookie list.  If you apply the same criteria to BrownE that you applied to Graham then a rookie list spot is relevant surely?

No. If he is worth anything then another club will pick him up. Graham & Browne are completely different. One was a kid who became a #1 ruck at a young age and the other struggled to break in (nothing against young Andy).A premiership contender has picked up Graham on a two year deal for 400k a season so he might just have ability. Although those with vendettas will never admit it.

Couldn't you find a bigger sig pic?

[Yeahright]

One was a kid who became a #1 ruck at a young age

For a club with no other ruckman, although people rooting for him won't admit it

There was 200 game veteran Troy Simmonds. And Browne was here which slaps your point for 6 considering it was a comparison between the two

Became #1 when Simmonds retired

[Coach]

One was a kid who became a #1 ruck at a young age

For a club with no other ruckman, although people rooting for him won't admit it

There was 200 game veteran Troy Simmonds. And Browne was here which slaps your point for 6 considering it was a comparison between the two

Became #1 when Simmonds retired

Simmo retired because Gus became #1

[tigs2011]

One was a kid who became a #1 ruck at a young age

For a club with no other ruckman, although people rooting for him won't admit it

There was 200 game veteran Troy Simmonds. And Browne was here which slaps your point for 6 considering it was a comparison between the two

Became #1 when Simmonds retired

Simmo retired because Gus became #1

[Penelope]

simmo retired because the AFL wouldn't allow him to play in a wheelchair

[gerkin greg]

Mr May 

[Coach]

Mr May 

[MADTIGER2010]

 

[Coach]

[the claw]

so to date our delistings/retirements/traded out is.

moore (r) =  f/a chaplin  kpd
connors =  f/a knights for/mid
webberley = pick 9 stringer mid/ kp for, vlastuin mid, mccrae mid, orourke mid, wines mid,
macdonald = pick 32 lowrie mid. towers mid, simpson mid.
graham (t) = pick 34 haynes mid/for, pongracic mid or one of the above if still there.
browne = pick 43 rodda kpd. kent mid.
white  = pick 50 duffy, warrell  sml/med forwards mids.
newman to vets 74 = jack hannath ruckman.

thing is if we had pick 25 one of the following would likely be available. tanner smith kpd, mason shaw kpf, liam mcbean ruckman. plus two or three mids we could rreally target a need with this pick im praying we have something up our sleeve to gain this pick it would be handy.




rookies
miller (r) = symonds ruckman
maric = kyle martin mid
turner = hartigan kpd
heslin =  james boyd mid
wright. sam dwyer
all mature players who deserve a crack at afl imo.
simon
darrou
verrier.


is anyone else hoping we offload one more and maybe put newman on the vet list proper.
i am really hopeful we can get a pick around 50. would dearly love one around 25 but 50 would do. would not hesitate to chop matt white he is a nothing player taking up the spot of a kid literally. he doesnt even make for good list balance.

[Mr Magic]

is anyone else hoping we offload one more

I sure am. Hoping Post or Jackson find a new home.

[gerkin greg]

hoping someone throws mcguane a freaking bone

preferably carlton

LOLOLOLOL

[one-eyed]

If Aaron Edwards is traded for a draft pick today then we're back to having just 3 free spots on our senior list. So if we want 4 draft picks then either someone else still out of contract has to go (McGuane/Post/White/Derickx still unsigned) or Newy will have to be placed as a vet outside the senior list.

[eliminator]

Do you think they will trade Post to North for Edwards?