McGuane or Miller

[Coach]

Milzy has retired but if you had a choice, who would you prefer to see play along side Riewoldt and Vickery?

[Phil Mrakov]

Milzy has retired but if you had a choice, who would you prefer to see play along side Riewoldt and Vickery?

Our Brad all the way.

Legend of the AFL.

[tigs2011]

Can we play a 2 tall forward line?

[Coach]

Can we play a 2 tall forward line?

If we get a decent half forward with good marking ability we can.

[Phil Mrakov]

Can we play a 2 tall forward line?

If we get a decent half forward with good marking ability we can.

Get Milzy!

[Tigeritis™©®]

This is a really hard question to answer.

If you put darling in the mix it would make it a much easier.
I would have to go Miller out of the two purely because Pia could be utilized in the marketing department at the club to model a new range of tiger apparel ie. guernsey, socks, shorts, swimwear, lingere etc.
.... Or has the club done this already? 

[Chuck17]

Could we have both each in a forward pocket?

That way there would be a plethora of stuff ups, handballs out the back, plus instead of double teaming Jack they could triple team as no one seriously rates the other two plebs.  Then we could listen to the usual moaners on how bad Jack is and how the back firing handballer is good for structure.

[the claw]

wheres the neither option.

theres 4 young tall options.  id rather put games into two of them at any given time.

[dwaino]

When your powers combine, I am McMiller.

[blaisee]

if mcguane is offered a contract, it must mean post is being shopped around

[Tigeritis™©®]

if mcguane is offered a contract, it must mean post is being shopped around

If mcguane is offered a contract, Cameron should be sacked.
I might start the Balme to punt road thread again.

[Eat_em_Alive]

neither, wheres the icon for lobotomy instead??

[bojangles17]

I dont completely understand the knock on mcguane, he can fill that role as a depth player as good as any. ffs, what are the chances of finding a pick 60+ to replace him that has hands like a steel trap and a leap like serge bubka...leave him be ,applaud the decision and move on

[the claw]

I dont completely understand the knock on mcguane, he can fill that role as a depth player as good as any. ffs, what are the chances of finding a pick 60+ to replace him that has hands like a steel trap and a leap like serge bubka...leave him be ,applaud the decision and move on

can think of two wa boys who i would rather see than mcguane. tom lee 21 yo  or alex howson 18yo  at pick 31. both can play forward or back. lee is ready to go. there is no real reason to hang onto sub standard players like mcguane for an eternity.
on top of that we have the real need of getting games into elton, astbury, griffiths and vickery all offer more as key forwrds than mcguane and we need to find at least two more up to standard kpfs.we wont be doing that by keeping and playing mcguane.

can i ask everyone how many nd picks should we use how many trades and free agents should we do.

imo we should use 5 nd picks 9, 29, 31, 50, 68.
at least two free agents and one trade.  thats a total of 8 players to the list proper meaning we need to cut two possibly three more players from the list proper.
as far as i can tell there are only three uncontracted players left mcguane, white , and derickx.