Richmond makes play for Dom Tyson [revisited?]

[Willy]

all well and good but we wont have much currency in terms of trading......unless we tank

How much currency do we need? HE is likely to say 'trade me to Richmond or i'l walk in the draft'
I guess it comes down to whether GWS will play hard ball or not.

[Eat_em_Alive]

Won't happen, so far away from the end of next season it aint funny...
So much can happen between now and then I doubt very much he will come.

One thing. I am certain of though is that we will. Find a good uncontracted player to bring on board next year, just not convinced he will feel the same way in 12 months time

[dwaino]

Caddy situation v2.0.2

[Dubstep Dookie]

Caddy situation v2.0.2

Hmmmm........

[Mr Magic]

Won't happen, so far away from the end of next season it aint funny...
So much can happen between now and then I doubt very much he will come.

Caddy situation v2.0.2

Agree. It's highly unlikely. Especially if we make the 8 next year.

[TigerLand]

Caddy wanted to go to Essendon last year and now has ended up at Geelong who finished higher than Essendon this year.

Has nothing to do with what draft pick we get, it comes down to what GWS will ask for Dom and whether we have it to trade or whether we are able to trade to get it.

If GWS want a top 3 pick or a top 5 pick and a player we'll need to look at upgrading our first round pick by off loading a player to a club with a pick and then handball that onto GWS. All comes down to what we want to give up for Dom.

Trade 1st round pick (Pick 12) and Shane Edwards to Port for pick 3.
Pick 3 to GWS for Dom Tyson.

Out First round pick, and Shane Edwards
In Dom Tyson.

[Willy]

Fair point. Although, I think Dom's desire to come to the promised land is greater than Caddy's desire to go to Tullamarine or wherever the stuff those plebs hang out. Plus the bombers had BJ(s) (pun intended) on their mind this off-season.
But yes, he wont come for free.

[Coach]

Caddy wanted to go to Essendon last year and now has ended up at Geelong who finished higher than Essendon this year.

Has nothing to do with what draft pick we get, it comes down to what GWS will ask for Dom and whether we have it to trade or whether we are able to trade to get it.

If GWS want a top 3 pick or a top 5 pick and a player we'll need to look at upgrading our first round pick by off loading a player to a club with a pick and then handball that onto GWS. All comes down to what we want to give up for Dom.

Trade 1st round pick (Pick 12) and Shane Edwards to Port for pick 3.
Pick 3 to GWS for Dom Tyson.

Out First round pick, and Shane Edwards
In Dom Tyson.

Since when did Port sign Greg Miller as their GM of football?

[Eat_em_Alive]

Im all for him to come down here  but time will tell and depends on how brainwashed he becomes too

[Mr Magic]

Out First round pick, and Shane Edwards
In Dom Tyson.

Why get rid of our best small forward? Edwards is still improving.

[Coach]

Pick 3 would be better than Edwards ever will be. Probably right off the bat too eg Dustin Martin. I certainly wouldn't on trade pick 3 for Dom Tyson...not unless they're chucking in Giles and Jezza Cameron as well.

[Mr Magic]

Pick 3 would be better than Edwards ever will be.

Probably.
Have to see how both go next year before packaging Shane with our first selection.
You'd want to be very sure Tyson is going to be a gun and I'm not sure you can say that yet.

[Coach]

Yep that's fair enough. And for all we know Edwards could kick 40+ next year.

[tigs2011]

Pick 3 would be better than Edwards ever will be. Probably right off the bat too eg Dustin Martin. I certainly wouldn't on trade pick 3 for Dom Tyson...not unless they're chucking in Giles and Jezza Cameron as well.

Agree. Keep pick 3 and push Tyson to PSD. 

[tigs2011]

Caddy situation v2.0.2

Going to Norf. Heard it in a meeting...