Richmond makes play for Dom Tyson [revisited?]

[YellowandBlackBlood]

Still have a chance with dylan shiels, dont stuff it up tigers 

Didn't he re-sign last year?

Yes but we missed our opportunity to trade for him as he wanted to leave gws.
We can trade for him at years end I believe but, we have less currency now than last year imo and could have been a shrewd pickup given there was heaps of talk about tyson and Adams trade. Shiels couldve been the one that got away.
Bookmark him going to cats, hawks or pies lol 

If we finish lower than last year, why would we have less currency now?

[Chuck17]

Think he is saying in terms of a club where a player would want to move to

[YellowandBlackBlood]

Think he is saying in terms of a club where a player would want to move to

Well if Tyson went to the Melbourne of last year, other players ill find our side an upgrade.

[TigerLand]

Perfect example of how pathetic our recruiting has been.

Should have given up a first round pick for this kid. Blind man could see he would be worth it. Wanted to come home, can't tell me we couldn't have beaten Melbourne for his signature. We were too soft at the trade table. GWS accepted an upgrade on a 1st rounder and a 2nd rounder. Our first rounder and a player would have done the job done.

Now don't make things up.
Melbourne traded pick 2 for Dom Tyson and pick 20 for pick 9 and pick 72 for pick 53.  There is no way GWS would have traded Dom to Richmond, we didn't have the currency.

Read the post properly.

GWS upgraded pick 9 to pick 2 (upgraded 1st round pick)
And pick 20 (a second rounder)

The higher picks aren't of value and could have easily been matched. We could have given gone hard and traded for what GWS wanted. Not rocket science we sat on our hands. We have currency but chose to keep the players we over rate.

[Chuck17]

Think he is saying in terms of a club where a player would want to move to

Well if Tyson went to the Melbourne of last year, other players ill find our side an upgrade.

Yep

[YellowandBlackBlood]

Perfect example of how pathetic our recruiting has been.

Should have given up a first round pick for this kid. Blind man could see he would be worth it. Wanted to come home, can't tell me we couldn't have beaten Melbourne for his signature. We were too soft at the trade table. GWS accepted an upgrade on a 1st rounder and a 2nd rounder. Our first rounder and a player would have done the job done.

Now don't make things up.
Melbourne traded pick 2 for Dom Tyson and pick 20 for pick 9 and pick 72 for pick 53.  There is no way GWS would have traded Dom to Richmond, we didn't have the currency.

Read the post properly.

GWS upgraded pick 9 to pick 2 (upgraded 1st round pick)
And pick 20 (a second rounder)

The higher picks aren't of value and could have easily been matched. We could have given gone hard and traded for what GWS wanted. Not rocket science we sat on our hands. We have currency but chose to keep the players we over rate.

I read the post.  You didn't read mine.

Now understand this - GWS ONLY TRADED TYSON BECAUSE THEY WANTED PICK 2.  They didn't care about pick 9 etc.  They wanted to have both picks 1&2.  They would never have traded him for pick 12 and if you think they would have you are deluded.

[Eat_em_Alive]

Still have a chance with dylan shiels, dont stuff it up tigers 

Didn't he re-sign last year?

Yes but we missed our opportunity to trade for him as he wanted to leave gws.
We can trade for him at years end I believe but, we have less currency now than last year imo and could have been a shrewd pickup given there was heaps of talk about tyson and Adams trade. Shiels couldve been the one that got away.
Bookmark him going to cats, hawks or pies lol 

If we finish lower than last year, why would we have less currency now?

Sorry just got home before, having a petturd moment 
I meant to say our players such as Foley, grigg, shedwards have less currency now than last year when we made finals and looked good. Now theyve been exposed.
You see, if were cooking suasages we need to offer sizzle.
Collingwood can get rid of their spuds by cooking up a bbq and trading for good players, we need to cook that stuffing bbq and make our spuds sizzle then offload them. No point trying to delust or trade once tge gas has gone out and the snags are cold right? Last year would have been a good opportunity off tge back off a good season.

[Francois Jackson]

Ooh dear

What a gun this kid will be

bump

someone again tell me how they dont rate him.

josh kelly for salem and dyson.

masterstroke.

[Phil Mrakov]

Ooh dear

What a gun this kid will be

bump

someone again tell me how they dont rate him.

josh kelly for salem and dyson.

masterstroke.

and please tell us how we could've got him?

[Eat_em_Alive]

Ooh dear

What a gun this kid will be

bump

someone again tell me how they dont rate him.

josh kelly for salem and dyson.

masterstroke.

and please tell us how we could've got him?

Offer something of value mate, in this case we would have been outbid with melbournes no1 pick. But need to offer value to trade. Say perhaps dusty and our first pick for their first pick and  tyson. Or take tyson and adams for said player and our first pick.

[Phil Mrakov]

Ooh dear

What a gun this kid will be

bump

someone again tell me how they dont rate him.

josh kelly for salem and dyson.

masterstroke.

and please tell us how we could've got him?

Offer something of value mate, in this case we would have been outbid with melbournes no1 pick. But need to offer value to trade. Say perhaps dusty and our first pick for their first pick and  tyson. Or take tyson and adams for said player and our first pick.

GWS weren't interested in Dustin

[Eat_em_Alive]

Ooh dear

What a gun this kid will be

bump

I blame that soley on the performance of his manager  poor form Walphy
So who do you think they wouldve taken then? And what for?


someone again tell me how they dont rate him.

josh kelly for salem and dyson.

masterstroke.

and please tell us how we could've got him?

Offer something of value mate, in this case we would have been outbid with melbournes no1 pick. But need to offer value to trade. Say perhaps dusty and our first pick for their first pick and  tyson. Or take tyson and adams for said player and our first pick.

GWS weren't interested in Dustin

[Phil Mrakov]

Ooh dear

What a gun this kid will be

bump

I blame that soley on the performance of his manager  poor form Walphy
So who do you think they wouldve taken then? And what for?


someone again tell me how they dont rate him.

josh kelly for salem and dyson.

masterstroke.

and please tell us how we could've got him?

Offer something of value mate, in this case we would have been outbid with melbournes no1 pick. But need to offer value to trade. Say perhaps dusty and our first pick for their first pick and  tyson. Or take tyson and adams for said player and our first pick.

GWS weren't interested in Dustin

Blank message

[Eat_em_Alive]

Ooh dear

What a gun this kid will be

bump



someone again tell me how they dont rate him.

josh kelly for salem and dyson.

masterstroke.

and please tell us how we could've got him?

Offer something of value mate, in this case we would have been outbid with melbournes no1 pick. But need to offer value to trade. Say perhaps dusty and our first pick for their first pick and  tyson. Or take tyson and adams for said player and our first pick.

GWS weren't interested in Dustin

Blank message

Sorry I put in wrong part......


I blame that soley on the performance of his manager  poor form Walphy
So who do you think they wouldve taken then? And what for?

[tony_montana]

wrong place wrong time, we wanted him, he wanted us we made a strong play the year before and it didn't take. Even if we had of gone for him this time round, Melbourne held all the aces, we weren't a realistic chance unfortunately