Cotchin's captaincy [merged]

[(•))(©™]

What has she done?

You don't even know but you spout generic argument for the sake of it.

I'm saying she's done nothing.
Clearer?

Now, what HAS she done?

[Go Richo 12]

Sorry, but you have lost count of the order of questioning. You brought into question of the nationality and gender of our president and the direction of the RFC. I asked what she has done wrong. You have answered that with another question. That tells me you can't formulate a response based on fact, you would rather use gender and race.

[WA Tiger]

Can someone please confirm who asked what, when, in what order and who has to answer that question first?

[(•))(©™]

Sorry, but you have lost count of the order of questioning. You brought into question of the nationality and gender of our president and the direction of the RFC. I asked what she has done wrong. You have answered that with another question. That tells me you can't formulate a response based on fact, you would rather use gender and race.

Yes..I understand what you have done.

What she has done wrong is, she's done nothing.

Perhaps now you could answer my question.

What has she done?

[Go Richo 12]

Overseen a board that has increased profits, memberships, infrastructure. You're just peeed off she hasn't sacked hardwick.

[rogerd3]

Harry high hair just doesn't cut personally.

[Francois Jackson]

Lol oversaw us idiots signing up in record numbers. She deserves full credit. Please.

She is very good at preaching stability and reminding us we would like to win a "final" 

Unfortunately all those things about infrastructure matter very little when you get embarrassed on field. Don't think the American fully understands that . Profit is nice when you actually know  what to do with it.

[Go Richo 12]

Has she, or has she not, overseen the most amount of sustained on field and off field success than any other president in rrecent years? Either way, my point is this, her gender and her ethnicity seems to be brought up as a reason why she fails as a president or is not up it, not her actions or achievements.

[🏅Dooks]

Has she, or has she not, overseen the most amount of sustained on field and off field success than any other president in rrecent years? Either way, my point is this, her gender and her ethnicity seems to be brought up as a reason why she fails as a president or is not up it, not her actions or achievements.

You keep referring to others slagging off her 'ethnicity' and 'race'. Ox nor anyone else has done this.  Being American is not an ethnicity nor a race. It's a nationality.

That aside, please quantify and qualify her specific involvement in the off field (and supposedly our on field) success, or did all this merely occur on her watch?

[(•))(©™]

Richo12 is so politically correct, she takes offence in articulate description.

[Go Richo 12]

Has she, or has she not, overseen the most amount of sustained on field and off field success than any other president in rrecent years? Either way, my point is this, her gender and her ethnicity seems to be brought up as a reason why she fails as a president or is not up it, not her actions or achievements.

You keep referring to others slagging off her 'ethnicity' and 'race'. Ox nor anyone else has done this.  Being American is not an ethnicity nor a race. It's a nationality.

That aside, please quantify and qualify her specific involvement in the off field (and supposedly our on field) success, or did all this merely occur on her watch?

Being American can very much be a race or ethnic. You're lack of intelligence in this area is astounding but not surprising. America is made up of many races and ethnicities. Just like australia. Anyway,the race i refer to is yarran, which ox has drawn attention to before and has had one poster challenge him on to which he had no courage to reply.

[Go Richo 12]

Richo12 is so politically correct, she takes offence in articulate description.

at articulate.

[WilliamPowell]

Has she, or has she not, overseen the most amount of sustained on field and off field success than any other president in rrecent years? Either way, my point is this, her gender and her ethnicity seems to be brought up as a reason why she fails as a president or is not up it, not her actions or achievements.

Sorry, but you have lost count of the order of questioning. You brought into question of the nationality and gender of our president and the direction of the RFC. I asked what she has done wrong. You have answered that with another question. That tells me you can't formulate a response based on fact, you would rather use gender and race.

Yes..I understand what you have done.

What she has done wrong is, she's done nothing.

Perhaps now you could answer my question.

What has she done?

Suppose it all depends on what people think the role of a president involves.

But back to the actual topic and whether we should consider replacing Cotchin as Captain and Robbo's article 

I think in a lot of cases clubs live by the ethos that their best player needs to be captain because somehow they are going to be great leaders.

I don't agree with that idea as it doesn't always work.

Look at GC, Ablett is without doubt their best player but I don't think he is a good captain. Ditto Pendlebury, gun player not sure he is ag great captain.

Yes at some clubs their best player is their captain eg Melbourne and Jones, Geelong and Selwood

But you look at other clubs Are Jack and McVeigh Sydney's best players? Bob Murphy at the Bulldogs?
Boak? No, actually You could even make case with Hodge and Hawthorn.

Maybe what the RFC needs to do is to look at having a leader rather thinking our best player is the best option.

As I said I thought Robbo's article was an very interesting read and a worthy one that opened up a interesting and probably important discussion

[🏅Dooks]

Has she, or has she not, overseen the most amount of sustained on field and off field success than any other president in rrecent years? Either way, my point is this, her gender and her ethnicity seems to be brought up as a reason why she fails as a president or is not up it, not her actions or achievements.

You keep referring to others slagging off her 'ethnicity' and 'race'. Ox nor anyone else has done this.  Being American is not an ethnicity nor a race. It's a nationality.

That aside, please quantify and qualify her specific involvement in the off field (and supposedly our on field) success, or did all this merely occur on her watch?

Being American can very much be a race or ethnic. You're lack of intelligence in this area is astounding but not surprising. America is made up of many races and ethnicities.

Erm........which is why you can't say being American is a race because there are many races in America.

Or, did you find Ox's comment on her being American to be derogatory to all races in the US ?

[(•))(©™]

Dooks's lack of intelligence , it says.