Who is on the knife's edge this year? (afl site)

[Smokey]

Dustin Martin

I reckon he might be sitting on the pointy end of the knife, not just the long edge.  Big year for young Dusty in so many ways.

[gerkin greg]

thread title gives me a hash craving

[MintOnLamb]

Hymie Glickstein

[Coach]

thread title gives me a hash craving

Rugged yet beautiful steak knives

[Chuck17]

WTF is a key to our structure, has plenty more years considering how long we gave clean knees Hughes and lazy Jay.

Cue CD

Is that question for me Chuck or are you just having a joke with Coach? By 'key to our structure' I'm referring to his position on the field. In 2011 he was a genuine forward option and kicked 30+ goals while also giving our ruckman an opportunity to rest. I expect Vickery, with added size and experience plus an injury free preseason, to fulfill both elements of his role significantly better this year too. 

Nah nothing to do with you Stripes, it was as serious a comment as I offer these days based  on the stupid article.

CD and I have differing views on Jay and I was expecting him to jump in (I love CD but on jay he is a bit off the planet)

[Coach]

You were a fan back in the day. Should have stayed on the bandwagon. I made a pooload of $$ by putting a grand on him to be Port's leading goal kicker in 2010. No one was expecting much but in Coach we trust Did average more goals for time on the field than Riewoldt btw 

Sorry rogerd, I hope I haven't big noted myself here. Vickery does need a good year. For himself and for us.

[eliminator]

WTF is a key to our structure, has plenty more years considering how long we gave clean knees Hughes and lazy Jay.

Cue CD

agree

[Chuck17]

I made a pooload of $$ by putting a grand on him to be Port's leading goal kicker in 2010.

Good on ya 

[Bengal]

Nahas for mine is the one that looks to be in jeopardy.. Still cant kick on his left and Sheds has definately moved past him for that forward spot. Nahas doesnt bring enough and we have moved past him..

[Coach]

I made a pooload of $$ by putting a grand on him to be Port's leading goal kicker in 2010.

Good on ya 

You forgot to reply to the bit about him averaging more goals than Riewoldt for time spent on the field.

[gerkin greg]

Sounds like adam thomson and his contested possies

If jay wasn't so fat he may have kicked more than jackie boy full stop

[Loui Tufga]

Sounds like adam thomson and his contested possies

If jay wasn't so fat he may have kicked more than jackie boy full stop

Sting ray Jay is only good for a handful of games a year anyway, never know a man to be so injury prone!

[Coach]

Sounds like adam thomson and his contested possies

If jay wasn't so fat he may have kicked more than jackie boy full stop

They averaged 2.8 and 2.9. shiltz though missed near 3 quarters against the crows, a quarter and 1/2 against Carlton and a fair amount of time on the sidelines against the Dogs. Fatness is an issue. All those problems playing at a club who has the least inside 50s of any club in the last 4 seasons

Sounds like adam thomson and his contested possies

If jay wasn't so fat he may have kicked more than jackie boy full stop

Sting ray Jay is only good for a handful of games a year anyway, never know a man to be so injury prone!

Very weird injuries. Riewoldt might get the odd injury if he ever performed a courageous act.

[Bengal]

No argument,,  Jack was kept and Jay has gone,,  i support Jack and hope Jay doesnt get a kick against us..  i support the team  not the player

[Coach]

It's a battle of the love children. Chuck v Coach & Shooter v Rooboy. Anyone else sticking their heads in actually has no idea what we're talking about