Your Predicted Top 12 Draft Picks

[torch]

Predict your top 12 draft picks.

Pick 1 - GWS
Pick 2 - GWS
Pick 3 - St Kilda
Pick 4 - Western Bulldogs
Pick 5 - Gold Coast
Pick 6 - Collingwood
Pick 7 - Brisbane
Pick 8 - North Melbourne
Pick 9 - Melbourne
Pick 10 - Collingwood
Pick 11 - West Coast
Pick 12 - Richmond 

[Judge Roughneck]

It's appears 2-12 are close no? 

[the claw]

in no particular order

boyd, marsh, sheed, acres, bontempelli, scharenburg, mcdonald, mccarthy, kelly, aish,lennon,salem.

[🏅Dooks]

in no particular order

boyd, marsh, sheed, acres, bontempelli, scharenburg, mcdonald, mccarthy, kelly, aish,lennon,salem.

In no particular order? Why bother

[Eat_em_Alive]

  wgaf
I want to know who will we most likely get?

[the claw]

in no particular order

boyd, marsh, sheed, acres, bontempelli, scharenburg, mcdonald, mccarthy, kelly, aish,lennon,salem.

In no particular order? Why bother

why not.
but lets see on a needs basis

1/ gws - boyd will be taken and hes not needed.
2/ gws - scharenberg
3/ stkilda - kelly
4/ wb - billings
5/ gcs - kolojashnij
6/ coll - bontempelli
7/ bris - sheed
8/ nm - mcdonald
9/melb - dunstan
10/ coll - cameron mccarthy
11/ wce - jon marsh
12/ rich - acres

just a few changes hard to work out exactly where they will go. have added dunstan  to the 12 he and scharenberg drove the south aussie champs win.  theres so much to like about him and imo hes a sfe bet.
also put billings back in and dropped aish. reckon billings has too much scope for improvement to be left out.
think it goes to show how tight it is with the top 15 or so.

aish well i think a lot of players have gone past him and for a top 10 pick he doesnt get enough contested ball. rather than be swayed by consensus i will go with gut feel and drop him down.

have left salem out because as stated before  i still wonder if his style can translate to afl. he relies on strength a bit and im not sure he will have that weapon at afl  and i dont think he has a lot of other options to fall back on. the other concern is his lack of performance against his better peers.

[Rampstar]

1-Boyd
2-Kelly
3-Billings
4-Bontempelli
5-Kolodashnij
6-Salem (Collingwood to go early to beat Melbourne and us to Christian Salem)
7-McCarthy
8-McDonald
9-Scharenberg (Melbourne missing out on Salem take Scharenberg here to shaft Collingwood)
10-Lennon (Collingwood take Lennon here to shaft RFC who wanted Salem or Lennon)
11-Acres (WCE to pull a surprise and go with Acres instead of Sheed or Freeman)
12-Aish (The big slider ends up at Richmond. Aish is class on the outside and will be a good player on a wing at the MCG)

[TigerLand]

I just hope we get either Salem or Lennon.

[Eat_em_Alive]

I just hope we get either Salem or Lennon.

From what most are saying here that would be a win 

[Rampstar]

under my top 12 scenario Collingwood again are the winners of the draft (Salem and Lennon - our preferred picks) but we too should be happy if we land an Aish mind you I wouldnt be surprised if we stuff it up and take someone like Zac Jones even though basically at AFL level he wont be more than a back pocket.

[mightytiges]

1. GWS - Boyd
2. GWS - Kelly
3. StK - Billings
4. WB - Bontempelli
5. GC - Kolodnashnij
6. Coll - Aish
7. Bris - McCarthy
8. NM - McDonald
9. Melb - Freeman
10. Coll - Scharenberg
11. WC - Sheed
12. Rich - Salem

[tigs2011]

1. Boyd
2. Kelly
3. Billings
4. Bontempelli
5. Kolodjashnij
6. Aish
7. McCarthy
8. McDonald
9. Salem
10. Scharenberg
11. Lennon
12. Freeman

[Phil Mrakov]

1. Boyd
2. Kelly
3. Billings
4. Bontempelli
5. Kolodjashnij
6. Aish
7. McCarthy
8. McDonald
9. Salem
10. Scharenberg
11. Lennon
12. Freeman

Do not want

[Rampstar]

Top 12 prediction thread game. No need for a new thread. Game is simple

1) you put your top 12 players in selected order

2) you get 5 points if you guess a player in the correct spot (everyone gets 5 points for McDonald)
3) you lose 3 points for every place in the draft for a player selected but not in your draft position- for example if you have someone at 5 and they go at 8 you lose 9 points.
4) you lose 10 points if one of your selections doesnt get picked in the first 12 picks.

Calculate your points at the end of the draft.

[tigs2011]

1. Boyd
2. Kelly
3. Billings
4. Bontempelli
5. Kolodjashnij
6. Aish
7. McCarthy
8. McDonald
9. Salem
10. Scharenberg
11. Lennon
12. Freeman

Do not want

Neither. Prefer Jones & Sheed but it's a prediction not a who I want thread.