Who made the decision to appoint Hardwick over Hinkley in 2009?

[The Big Richo]

Anyone notice the footage of Hinkley on the ground after last night's win?

Contrast that with Hardwick after the Sydney game.

[Chuck17]

Whoever selected Hardwick has cost us finals success.

Ken Hinkley is clearly a better coach in every aspect then Hardwick!

You needed a brand new thread of this?

Couldn't you have just used your "Sack Harwick" thread 

Agree merge thread and give strike

[JP Tiger]

Forget the respective coaching departments, what we really need to steal from Port are some of those great seat covers!      It worked for them, so we have to do it too! 

[Rampstar]

None of you guys would have supported Hinkley at the time and you knew it. Hardwick won the job Hinkley its well known came 2nd in the interview process. I have no complaints about the process, to get to those two last means that the process was right. From memory most of you wanted Rawlings who has been at Melbourne for a few years now. Hardwick has taken us to 2 finals in a row. Not a bad effort considering the last 30 years. I like Hinkley he exhibits mongrel and is a good coach, but we have what we have. So lets get on with it.

[Hard Roar Tiger]

Can't argue with that Rampa. Not bad for a numbnut

[Judge Roughneck]

None of you guys would have supported Hinkley at the time and you knew it. Hardwick won the job Hinkley its well known came 2nd in the interview process. I have no complaints about the process, to get to those two last means that the process was right. From memory most of you wanted Rawlings who has been at Melbourne for a few years now. Hardwick has taken us to 2 finals in a row. Not a bad effort considering the last 30 years. I like Hinkley he exhibits mongrel and is a good coach, but we have what we have. So lets get on with it.

Yes they did...

http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Gqj6VItiw7k

Many could see he was a machine and just what the club needed.

Rewind the tape

[Francois Jackson]

None of you guys would have supported Hinkley at the time and you knew it. Hardwick won the job Hinkley its well known came 2nd in the interview process. I have no complaints about the process, to get to those two last means that the process was right. From memory most of you wanted Rawlings who has been at Melbourne for a few years now. Hardwick has taken us to 2 finals in a row. Not a bad effort considering the last 30 years. I like Hinkley he exhibits mongrel and is a good coach, but we have what we have. So lets get on with it.

agree with this. I will put my hand up and say I wanted hardwick mainly due to his hardness as a player.

Im starting to think he is all bark and no bite

[Francois Jackson]

You must lead sad lives fellas.

yeah poo house. Spent the day feeding the birds with my kids and at the chocolate factory at the yarra glen.

Off to see a shrink Monday my lifes stuffed

[(•))(©™]

There's just not enough pornography at the club

[Hard Roar Tiger]

You must lead sad lives fellas.

yeah poo house. Spent the day feeding the birds with my kids and at the chocolate factory at the yarra glen.

Off to see a shrink Monday my lifes stuffed

 

[YellowandBlackBlood]

None of you guys would have supported Hinkley at the time and you knew it. Hardwick won the job Hinkley its well known came 2nd in the interview process. I have no complaints about the process, to get to those two last means that the process was right. From memory most of you wanted Rawlings who has been at Melbourne for a few years now. Hardwick has taken us to 2 finals in a row. Not a bad effort considering the last 30 years. I like Hinkley he exhibits mongrel and is a good coach, but we have what we have. So lets get on with it.

[Judge Roughneck]

None of you guys would have supported Hinkley at the time and you knew it. Hardwick won the job Hinkley its well known came 2nd in the interview process. I have no complaints about the process, to get to those two last means that the process was right. From memory most of you wanted Rawlings who has been at Melbourne for a few years now. Hardwick has taken us to 2 finals in a row. Not a bad effort considering the last 30 years. I like Hinkley he exhibits mongrel and is a good coach, but we have what we have. So lets get on with it.

agree with this. I will put my hand up and say I wanted hardwick mainly due to his hardness as a player.

Im starting to think he is all bark and no bite

I didn't want hardwick cause I thought he was an average player and merely dirty

[Smokey]

I didn't want hardwick cause I thought he was an average player and merely dirty

So was Malthouse.

[(•))(©™]

So was Geez and look at the success he's had

[Judge Roughneck]

I didn't want hardwick cause I thought he was an average player and merely dirty

So was Malthouse.

I'm also bias against Essendon

I concede hardwick had a successful period early however I believe he lost the plot some time ago