Yeah or nay - Marty Clarke

[tdy]

What do people think of Marty Clarke recently delisted by the Pies? When he first arrived he seemed to have what it takes while being on a learning curve.
In his second stint he has only averaged 12 games a year and has got dropped. 

So was he just a flash in the pan or did Malthiuse get the best out of him and FIGJAM cant?

Which leads into should we grab him on the rookie list or for depth?

[Phil Mrakov]

R u high

[Tiger Tragic]

Nay thanks. Poor mans Hanley

[tdy]

R u high

If you noticed I havent voted. Im up in the air here on this one, I just saw his name delisted and wondered what others thought because his second stint has been ordinary but 2 years have been under Bucks. He did show a lot of promise to be a running defender when he first started.

[Chuck17]

Is Mcmahon still available

[bojangles17]

hit his peak within his first few seasons and been all down hill since, an emphatic NO ty

[Diocletian]

hit his peak within his first few seasons and been all down hill since, an emphatic NO ty

So I take it if we do get him we won't see you turn around and say "whoa, bloke can seriously play, another shrewd move by Blair just quietly"....

[the claw]

hit his peak within his first few seasons and been all down hill since, an emphatic NO ty

So I take it if we do get him we won't see you turn around and say "whoa, bloke can seriously play, another shrewd move by Blair just quietly"....

lol

[Go Richo 12]

Yeah, nah.

[Francois Jackson]

delete thread ASAP

[The Big Richo]

I reckon he is just the type that will excite Hartley.

Blair is that shrewd I think he will be planning to snatch him for our first round pick and Cotchin, which he will give to the Pies despite the fact they have already delisted him.

[Judge Roughneck]

i like him

[scjhammo]

please ur kidding we might as well get JON back from WA...... marty Clarke another left footer like a mister grigg who has no right foot

[eliminator]

No

[tony_montana]