Demon Jack Trengove could be traded to Richmond (Herald-Sun)

[Tommy]

I just don't see the logic in this.
Not like he was carving things up in the AFL prior to his injury concerns.
He might end up being a reasonable contributor but don't expect too much.
Hasn't proven anything at the elite level yet and at 23 the clock is well ticking.
Lets use 12 to land a great young player.

What, like Lennon, last year.

Get real, 12 is a gamble.

[one-eyed]

Melbourne is now exploring a deal put by Richmond for Jack Trengove, which requires them to give pick 23 and Trengove to the Tigers for pick 12. This would torpedo the Magpies' chances of securing pick 23 for Lumumba.

Adelaide has also expressed interest in Trengove and it is understood the former Melbourne captain and number two draft pick, who is contracted player for next year at Melbourne, was weighing up his options at the family home in Naracoorte this weekend.

Richmond has already done some preliminary medical examination of Trengove but was due to undertake further tests this week.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/sweetener-on-table-to-seal-dayne-beams-move-to-brisbane-20141012-115149.html#ixzz3FwlnbLlS

[one-eyed]

Adelaide’s interest in Trengove returning home may have been short lived.

The Crows are now likely to retain their first-round national draft selection and use it to recruit a key-position teenager in next month’s national draft.

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/sport/afl/cats-star-joins-the-lions-midfield/story-fnca0u4y-1227088217266

[Chuck17]

I just don't see the logic in this.
Not like he was carving things up in the AFL prior to his injury concerns.
He might end up being a reasonable contributor but don't expect too much.
Hasn't proven anything at the elite level yet and at 23 the clock is well ticking.
Lets use 12 to land a great young player.

What, like Lennon, last year.

Get real, 12 is a gamble.

Are you saying Lennon is a failure ?

[Phil Mrakov]

Adelaide only interseted after Richo let it all out

[Judge Roughneck]

FO harryo

FO Adelaide

[tony_montana]

Melbourne is now exploring a deal put by Richmond for Jack Trengove, which requires them to give pick 23 and Trengove to the Tigers for pick 12. This would torpedo the Magpies' chances of securing pick 23 for Lumumba.

Adelaide has also expressed interest in Trengove and it is understood the former Melbourne captain and number two draft pick, who is contracted player for next year at Melbourne, was weighing up his options at the family home in Naracoorte this weekend.

Richmond has already done some preliminary medical examination of Trengove but was due to undertake further tests this week.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/sweetener-on-table-to-seal-dayne-beams-move-to-brisbane-20141012-115149.html#ixzz3FwlnbLlS

This makes no sense - he's either had a medical or he hasn't - surely you don't do preliminary tests - do the deal then do extensive tests?

[Judge Roughneck]

Its makes sense.Medical can takes more than one day. Is. Its not beyond the realms of possibility he's done part one and yet to do part two

You would hope the club is attempting to anticipate how his body will hold up in the future.

50 million pound transfers in soccer get cancled depending on medical results. One would hope rfc don't f it up given the history ala cogs

[scjhammo]

  Y WOULD WE BE CHASING THIS KID HE PLAYED TWO GAMES THIS YEAR INJURY PRON... IF WE WERE GOING TO OFFER MAYBE A SECOND OR THIRD ROUND PICK ETC OK AND HO[PE FOR THE BEST BUT PLEASE OUR FIRST ROUND SELECTION ON A PLAYER WHO WE DONT EVEN KNOW WILL MAKE IT BACK ON THE GROUND... AND PEOPLE THOUGHT MITCH ROBINSON WAS A RISK AT LEAST MITCH PLAYS WEEK IN AND WEEK OUT DONT DO THE TRADE TIGERS WASTE AND NOT GOOD FOR THE CLUB

[Penelope]

so many posts that dont seem to take into account that the proposed deal downgrades our first pick, not just lose it.

when you look at it this way;

You know what? If it is and they have done their due diligence on the injury then good on them for going for it. Trengove (fit) and pick 23 should be better than 12 in theory anyway.

the prospect seems ok.

i would be interested in what those against think of tony's comments

[Willy]

I just don't see the logic in this.
Not like he was carving things up in the AFL prior to his injury concerns.
He might end up being a reasonable contributor but don't expect too much.
Hasn't proven anything at the elite level yet and at 23 the clock is well ticking.
Lets use 12 to land a great young player.

He was very good in his second season.

[Phil Mrakov]

Y WOULD WE BE CHASING THIS KID HE PLAYED TWO GAMES THIS YEAR INJURY PRON... IF WE WERE GOING TO OFFER MAYBE A SECOND OR THIRD ROUND PICK ETC OK AND HO[PE FOR THE BEST BUT PLEASE OUR FIRST ROUND SELECTION ON A PLAYER WHO WE DONT EVEN KNOW WILL MAKE IT BACK ON THE GROUND... AND PEOPLE THOUGHT MITCH ROBINSON WAS A RISK AT LEAST MITCH PLAYS WEEK IN AND WEEK OUT DONT DO THE TRADE TIGERS WASTE AND NOT GOOD FOR THE CLUB

Shutup

How many games did he play prior to this years injury? 

[scjhammo]

yeah well he wasn't injured then was he mate so use common sense ur risking someone who played two games with a foot he isn't even running at the moment so he is still a long way off..... if you want trades and new players I think we should be targeting someone that is sound and right to go...


How many games he play prior to being injured that comment isn't even relevant u look at the year that just past, that's like saying gee how good was vickerys games  2013 last year at the g round 2 against the saints when he took about 13-14 marks and busted packs li :thumbsupving in the past

[YellowandBlackBlood]

yeah well he wasn't injured then was he mate so use common sense ur risking someone who played two games with a foot he isn't even running at the moment so he is still a long way off..... if you want trades and new players I think we should be targeting someone that is sound and right to go...


How many games he play prior to being injured that comment isn't even relevant u look at the year that just past, that's like saying gee how good was vickerys games  2013 last year at the g round 2 against the saints when he took about 13-14 marks and busted packs li :thumbsupving in the past

He is running...........

[scjhammo]

his running yeah about as fast as my granma who is 90......