Who was the toughest ever player at Tigerland?

[YellowandBlackBlood]

FFS why isn't Mopsy Fraser on the list?

The Poll is for Tigers of the past 50 years since we moved home games to the MCG. That's why there's no Dyer, Fraser, etc ...

The title is a little misleading then…it can't be toughest EVER! Should be "toughest since moving to the MCG".

[(•))(©™]

IMO, it's NOT the obvious "blokes"

Someone like the Flea, pound for pound was hard as stuff and for years.

Another tough bastard was Paul Broderick.A lot of his hardness went unnoticed.

Scotty Turner was tough as stuff too.

Agree 100% Ox. Flea and Brodders were like sappers diving into contests to get the footy with no regard for their own safety.   

Smart man!

[eliminator]

IMO, it's NOT the obvious "blokes"

Someone like the Flea, pound for pound was hard as stuff and for years.

Another tough bastard was Paul Broderick.A lot of his hardness went unnoticed.

Scotty Turner was tough as stuff too.

I would add to that list Tony Free.

[Dice]

Two mentions of Broderick ? You blokes have seriously lost your marbles. Broderick was a bit soft actually. Pretty good player though.

Dyer , Fraser and Roger Dean were before my time but I heard stories.
Ricky McLean and Neil Balme were hard bastards in the 70s. They'd be my choice as the hardest tigers.
Malthouse , Weightman , Woosha Welsh , Terry Smith  , Jim Jess in the early 80s. Cloke didn't take any crap either. Barry Young in the late 80s.
Tony Free in the early 90s. Scott Turner was pretty tough.
That's about it.

[the claw]

different type of toughness duncan kellaway,

[Gigantor]

For me its St Frances clearly.
However I have also heard enough stories to mention Don Mopsy fraser who many say was meaner and tougher than captain blood

[Big Bloke]

Two mentions of Broderick ? You blokes have seriously lost your marbles. Broderick was a bit soft actually. Pretty good player though.

Dyer , Fraser and Roger Dean were before my time but I heard stories.
Ricky McLean and Neil Balme were hard bastards in the 70s. They'd be my choice as the hardest tigers.
Malthouse , Weightman , Woosha Welsh , Terry Smith  , Jim Jess in the early 80s. Cloke didn't take any crap either. Barry Young in the late 80s.
Tony Free in the early 90s. Scott Turner was pretty tough.
That's about it.

Brodders was not soft, that is ridiculous neph. Doesn't belong in this discussion but soft bah geez! Nope. Freezer was scary.

I would like to nominate Brett Deledio.

[Dice]

Brodders was not soft, that is ridiculous neph. Doesn't belong in this discussion but soft bah geez! Nope. Freezer was scary.

You and I have this debate every bloody xmas. I'm not getting into it with you again. He was soft.
Nice to see you finally took my advice and joined this site.

[tiga]

Brodders was not soft, that is ridiculous neph. Doesn't belong in this discussion but soft bah geez! Nope. Freezer was scary.

You and I have this debate every bloody xmas. I'm not getting into it with you again. He was soft.
Nice to see you finally took my advice and joined this site.

Dice are you talking to Santa Claus? 

[Big Bloke]

Brodders was not soft, that is ridiculous neph. Doesn't belong in this discussion but soft bah geez! Nope. Freezer was scary.

You and I have this debate every bloody xmas. I'm not getting into it with you again. He was soft.
Nice to see you finally took my advice and joined this site.

[tiga]

         
     
         
             

[Chuck17]

We need a poll for the toughest poster

[Diocletian]

We need a poll for the toughest poster

Well obviously anyone with "big" in their username is someone not to be stuffed with....

[Owl]

My immediate reaction, u don't go chucking that in your name if you are not prepared to back it up

[Chuck17]

OK so far that makes it;

Big Bloke          1
The Big Richo   1