Should Chris Newman follow Adam Goodes lead??

[the claw]

If Adam Goodes was really serious he wouldn't be playing this year at all. Clear as daylight that he should have quit at the end of last season as his form waned.

As for this notion of he has offered to play in the NEAFL, I don't buy it. Personally, he was about to be dropped. Facts are his pre-season form was terrible, hence why he was the sub the last 2 weeks and if the swans very serious and prepared to make the tough calls he wouldn't have played rds 1 & 2

He should have quit last year as well, just like Newman should have.

Sometimes clubs shouldn't give players the option, like what we did and what Sydney did with Goodes. They need to have the courage to say "thanks but time for you to move on"

goodes has been shot for more thnan 1 yr.
and he didnt do a thing for the team. he did a typical goodes sook act and looked after himself first.

me iagree do away with the sub rule in fact do away with the sub rule and three on the bench. two on the bench a game is plenty.

[(•))(©™]

But he's the Martin Luther King of AFL......   

[Hard Roar Tiger]

But he's the Martin Luther King of AFL......   

And you're the Malcolm X of the RFC - go figure....

[mightytiges]

Newy was good tonight. Did far more in one game as a defensive forward than Morris did in two plus three preseason games.

[Diocletian]

Newy was good tonight. Did far more in one game as a defensive forward than Morris did in two plus three preseason games.

Says more about Morris than Newman really. Tipping the longer the season goes and the better the opponents get, the more he'll start to struggle.

[(•))(©™]

They played Brisbane. .....

[TigerMonk]

Chris Newman played a very good game last night. He was clearly a standout player & was their to help at all times 

His career is not done yet 

[Jackstar is back!!!]

Chris Newman played a very good game last night. He was clearly a standout player & was their to help at all times 

His career is not done yet 

Totally agree
Played well especially when the game was in dispute early

[Gigantor]

yep good game by newman

[Chuck17]

 

[cub]

I got teased all night on newmans game, well you can only do what you can I Spose and in that game he was good!
Goodes my most disliked player, enough said on that

[MintOnLamb]

if you had the choice of Newman or Goodes to play for RFC (in their present state) who would you pick?

[the claw]

if you had the choice of Newman or Goodes to play for RFC (in their present state) who would you pick?

goodes he would at least allow us to structure up with a third tall fwd.

newman had a good game they all had a good game bar one or two.

the thing to ask is. was it a flat track bully game where we excelled with little pressure applied which has been our way under hardwick. or was it a game of genuine improvement.
me im just gunna say it was a game we should have won easy and we did.

[Willy]

Yeah I'm not getting carried away with that win. Our intensity and tackling was up though, which was the most pleasing thing for me.

[cub]

I got teased all night on newmans game, well you can only do what you can I Spose and in that game he was good!
Goodes my most disliked player, enough said on that

Visionary - Boooooo