Ottens, what was I thinking?
19 June 2004
Mike Sheahan
Herald Sun
AT the risk of pushing Richmond supporters to an even deeper level of depression, it is only 24 months since they were at the door to Dreamland.
Richmond opened the 2002 season with a six-goal win over Collingwood in front of 65,350 people, with the Big Os, Richo and Otto, on song.
Richo booted six; Ottens dominated in the ruck, took nine marks and kicked four.
Given Richmond's top-four finish in 2001 and Ottens' selection in the All-Australian team, the Tigers seemed ready to take on the world.
Since then, Richmond has won 17 of 55 games, and, if Ottens hasn't regressed, he has failed to keep up.
What is beyond debate is that my decision to rank him at No. 15 in the pre-season top 50 hasn't been justified. In fact, what it has been is embarrassing.
There are times when predictions simply prove to be wrong. Then there are times when calls that look decidedly wrong might only be premature. Peter Everitt, for example, was listed at No. 4 in my top 50 players before the 1999 season.
Despite his St Kilda best-and-fairest win in 2001, you could argue he still is maturing. He will win a best-and-fairest at a second club this year and he is better than he has ever been.
One thing that hasn't changed in football is that big blokes take more time. But how much time is enough?
Ottens, 24, is in his seventh season and has played 123 games. Is that long enough? It should be, yet Everitt is at his best at 30, Melbourne's Jeff White is in career-best form in his 10th season, West Coast's Michael Gardiner, the best ruckman in the competition last year, started in 1997.
Perhaps Ottens simply is taking time to mature. Or, does he lack the urgency to ever reach what has been seen to be his destiny?
Ottens was the player with the red bullet in my 2004 top 50, perched at No. 15. Kevin Bartlett recently criticised the selection, terming it "extraordinary". Yet the same Bartlett said at the same time Ottens had the size and talent to be "the best player in the game".
I was happy to keep him safe at 15.
John Barnes, the most recent No. 1 ruckman in a Victorian premiership team (Essendon, 2000), believes Ottens isn't enjoying his football. He likened him to Melbourne's White, who laboured through 2003 before blossoming this year.
Yet Ottens looks fit enough. It's his body language, his urgency that's at issue. It's as if he takes tranquillisers before a game.
In technical terms, there is nothing he can't do: he is an expert ruckman, a reliable mark, a super kick for his size, and he is brave and durable.
Kevin Sheedy hints we are impatient with big blokes. He cites White and throws the names of Josh Fraser and David Hille into the mix.
Fraser is in his fifth season, Hille his fourth. Fraser has become a good player at 22. Hille, 23, has shown plenty, but is struggling this year.
There is a school of thought Ottens may need to follow Everitt's path and start afresh elsewhere.
Two clubs in his home state of South Australia would be more than happy to test that theory.
The Crows, in particular. Matty Clarke is nearing the end, and the former Glenelg boy would be welcomed with open arms.
Adelaide is second-last and might have a couple of aces in the poker game played between all clubs before the national draft.
On the other hand, can you imagine the new Richmond coach – and there will be one – willingly parting with Ottens?
Hardly. He may not be the 15th most valuable player in the competition after 12 rounds this year, but he has the natural ability to match his huge frame.
Only Everitt has registered more hitouts this year, and White is a Brownlow Medal fancy; Everitt and White finally are the best ruckmen in the competition.
Ottens has time on his side, but the clock is ticking louder than ever.
What John Barnes says
"HE'S either got an injury or he should be playing in the seconds; simple as that.
"I love the bloke; it just drives me nuts the way he's playing. I reckon he's huge. It's criminal to see a bloke with the frame, the size, the talent he's got playing like he is.
"He should be in the top three (ruckmen) in the competition.
"I'm starting to lose faith in him.
"He's obviously not enjoying his footy. I'm tipping he's hating going to training, being at the club, going to the gym. He'd be saying things like `I'm not getting a kick, what am I doing here?'
"Brad Ottens should ring up Jeff White and ask him how he turned it round. If Jeff White can turn it round like he has, so can Brad Ottens.
"I hope he does."
What Kevin Bartlett says
"BRAD Ottens has been a big disappointment to the Tigers. A couple of years ago, I thought he was an extraordinary talent; such a beautiful kick.
"I think he's got to get a bit more urgency into his game; I think we've got to see him break into a sweat.
"I think he's got to take more marks, I think he's got to win more of the ball; I don't think it's enough just to do the ruckwork as a designated ruckman, and I really do think he's got to sit down and be tougher on himself, and go out with the thought that he should be the best player on the ground every time he steps on to the ground.
"I think Mike Sheahan might have put him in his top five or 10 players at the start of the year, which was an extraordinary thing by Mike to do.
"He may have been reasonable this season, but the Tigers need more than reasonable players, and when you've got the talent of Brad Ottens, he has to do better.
"He's got to get a bit more urgency into his game, a bit more excitement, and I think he's got to lift his own standards . . .
"He's got the talent, he's got the size, it just depends on whether he has got the will to make himself the best player in the game and, so far, he hasn't."
(Bartlett was speaking on SEN)
http://www.heraldsun.news.com.au/footy/common/story_page/0,8033,%255E20123,00.html