Trade and PSD offerings

[mightytiges]

Any interest in the below offerings mentioned so far as possibly changing clubs in either the trade week or the PSD (if they're still available at pick 5)?

Adelaide: Fergus Watts

Brisbane: Brad/Chris Scott, Beau McDonald

Carlton: Brendan Fevola, Lance Whitnall, Matthew Lappin

Collingwood: Richard Cole, Brayden Shaw, Jason Cloke, Shane Woewodin, Ryan Lonie

Essendon: Marc Bullen, Sam Hunt, Mark Alvey

Fremantle: Graham Polak, Gilmore

Geelong: James Bartel

Hawthorn: Jonathan Hay

Kangaroos: Daniel Motlop, Shannon Grant

Melbourne: Clint Bizzell

Port Adelaide: Byron Pickett

St Kilda: Brendan Goddard?

W.Bulldogs: Sam Power, Jade Rawlings.

West Coast: Daniel McConnell, Andrew McDougall

[Razorblade]

Adelaide: Fergus Watts - He likes to drink and party too much from what i've heard, and i believe its true considering his younger brother and a lot of his mates are the same way (seen it first hand!  )

Brisbane: Brad/Chris Scott - Both too old.

Carlton: Brendan Fevola, Lance Whitnall, Matthew Lappin - No, no and no.

Collingwood: Richard Cole, Brayden Shaw, Jason Cloke, Shane Woewodin - No, maybe, maybe, no.

Essendon: Marc Bullen, Sam Hunt - No and yes.

Fremantle: Graham Polak - Cost too much to acquire, no.

Geelong: James Bartel - We'd have to give up something special to get him, no.

Kangaroos: Daniel Motlop - Wants to be closer to the NT, thats why his leaving Kangas.

Melbourne: Adam Yze - NOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!

Port Adelaide: Byron Pickett - Too old.

St Kilda: Brendan Goddard - I like him, a lot of people dont, wouldn't want to give up too much for him though.

W.Bulldogs: Nathan Eagleton - No.

West Coast: Daniel McConnell - Yes.

[cub]

James Bartel would be the only one I would be interested in.
Depends on what he is after $$$ and commitment wise. In this day and age you would like to build a loyal list ala Brisbane the last few years, making a sacrifice so as to play as a team in the finals. You don't need mercenaries that chase the $ - would not be good for moral.

As for the rest, I can see why their clubs dont want them  - Build our own team and chase maybe 1 big trade / swap.

[mightytiges]

Added Shannon Grant, Jonathan Hay and possibly Luke Power to the above list.

We all know most of these contractual disputes are worked out in time and usually there's only 1or 2 big names up for grabs each year, but with pick 5 in the PSD it would be handy for us if a number of players are still wanting to change clubs. It's a shame last year when we had first pick there was no top quality players such as a Gehrig or Hamill on offer.

[Razorblade]

What are you talking about MT, we got Knobel, his a gun! 

[WilliamPowell]

Collingwood: Richard Cole, Brayden Shaw, Jason Cloke, Shane Woewodin

I reckon young Shaw would be worth considering - only because he was a stand out junior and Tezza always says you don't lose your ability just your confidence (look at Pettifer  ) Cole - they'd want too much and I don't reckon he is worth very much. As for Jason Cloke -  nope and poor old Woewoewoefuldin - over rated NOOOOOOOOOOOOO 

Geelong: James Bartel

Would love him but Geelong would want a 1st round pick for him and he isn't worth pick 8 IMHO. And I reckon the Cats would be difficult to deal with after the Otten$ deal of last year - seeing we got the better of that deal 

Throw in Salopek from Port Adelaide - I reckon we could swing a deal for this kid

[mightytiges]

Forgot about Steven Salopek WP. I've added him and Mark Alvey to the above list.

What are you talking about MT, we got Knobel, his a gun! 

Knobel is a gun compared to who I've just been told may be coming to Punt Road  .

[Razorblade]

Forgot about Steven Salopek WP. I've added him and Mark Alvey to the above list.

What are you talking about MT, we got Knobel, his a gun! 

Knobel is a gun compared to who I've just been told may be coming to Punt Road  .

Who may that be?  ???

[mightytiges]

Forgot about Steven Salopek WP. I've added him and Mark Alvey to the above list.

What are you talking about MT, we got Knobel, his a gun! 

Knobel is a gun compared to who I've just been told may be coming to Punt Road  .

Who may that be?  ???

Two bombers - a young 192cm defender and an ex-bulldog    

[tigertough12]

Forgot about Steven Salopek WP. I've added him and Mark Alvey to the above list.

What are you talking about MT, we got Knobel, his a gun! 

Knobel is a gun compared to who I've just been told may be coming to Punt Road  .

Who may that be?  ???

Two bombers - a young 192cm defender and an ex-bulldog    

Who's the 192cm defender and what do we give up?

[H Tiger]

No way we will pick up Alvy he is a hack. Two clubs, bad knee, no games, too old.

Is this from a reliable source MT?

Luke Power would be worth a first round draft pick. Would really compliment our midfield and can rotate thround the forward line interchanging with N. Brown, was a great goal sneak with the Lions originally.

[Razorblade]

Mt, just heard a rumour, Alvey and Hunt for 3rd rounder, is this what you are referring to?

[mightytiges]

Mt, just heard a rumour, Alvey and Hunt for 3rd rounder, is this what you are referring to?

I wasn't told what we're giving up for them but yep they are the two Razor . On the bombers forum bomberblitz I've read our 3rd rounder for Hunt rumour.   

No way we will pick up Alvy he is a hack. Two clubs, bad knee, no games, too old.

Is this from a reliable source MT?

I couldn't agree more about Alvey HT but the source is normally on the money 9 times out of 10.

We finally get a draft right last year and now it looks like we're going to stuff it again this year chasing fringe AFL/VFL duds who couldn't get a game in the worst Essendon side for over 25 years. Not happy Jan!   

[Razorblade]

Agree on Alvey.

Hunt is interesting though, young defender (23 in April) and  i've constantly heard bombers supporters say he should be given more of a go (this is going back to 2004 even).

Apparently Sheedy has it out for him.

[mightytiges]

Hunt is interesting though, young defender (23 in April) and  i've constantly heard bombers supporters say he should be given more of a go (this is going back to 2004 even).

Apparently Sheedy has it out for him.

Hunt has been around since 2001. So he's spent 5 years on an AFL list yet has only played 7 games in total (3 in 2002 and 4 this year). It's just a dumb trade all-round for us. They'll both be delisted anyhow so we could get Hunt with a late pick (i.e. for practically nothing) if we really wanted to. If this goes through Sheeds will be quietly chuckling to himself over pulling another swifty.