Unlike most by the looks of things I'm pretty happy with the thought of getting Yarran. But I also agree with most that we should only be offering our second round pick. After all they pretty much want him gone so we are in the box seat you would hope.
Now that Bennel is off the table we should throw the kitchen sink at Carlisle. I'd be more than happy to give up our first pick for this bloke. He is a very good player and could hold down a key back roll for the next 6,7,8, years. He has been bogged down with all the Essendon crap for such a long time i think his best footy is still yet to come.
A backline with Carlisle, Rance, Grimes, Vlastuin, Yarran and maybe a young guy like Castagna could do the job defensively most weeks but with also the run and carry of a top 4 side.
Just as important this trade period IMO is to off load a few others for picks or players. Why not take a rick? Our list isn't a top 4 list but our best 22 maybe could be if we are brave.
Astbury and our 3rd round pick for Redden from Brisbane would be a steal. Would be easily in our starting 18 and a player like Grigg would be squeezed out.
Griffiths for a second round pick. Griff isn't going to take us anywhere IMO. Trade now while he still has currency.
Conca for Lycett from WCE. Not a star be any stretch but could hold down a second ruck spot comfortably IMO. And Conca IMO is just an "in-betweener " not even in our best 22 IMO.
B. Ellis for Mitchell Grigg from Adelaide and maybe their 3 rounder. I just think Ellis is the most scared footballer I have ever seen in a Tigers jumper. Scared of getting hurt but by far worse than that, scared of making a mistake. And Mitchell is big bodied mid that we need. One less soft footballer can't hurt.
Morris and a 3rd rounder for Jake Neade from Port Adelaide. He could be the small forward we have lacked for as long as I can remember. And Morris seems to have had a line through his name.
So we could end up with
Carlisle
Yarran
Redden
Lycett
M. Grigg
Neade
And still have 1 pick in the second round, and a few after the 3 round.
And lose
Astbury
Griffiths
Conca
Ellis
Morris
All players with massive deficiencies that we wouldn't miss.