Which Tiger players are elite?

[one-eyed]

As the title says - Which Tiger players are elite? At this time last year, Champion Data said Lids, Jack, Titch & Rance.

Also, who of our younger players do you think could become elite?

[Hard Roar Tiger]

Lids, Jack, Rance, Cotch & Dusty.
All elite but none have proven to be in the "greats" bracket yet.
The next tier down is very skinny tho

[🏅Dooks]

Cotchin:-

2013 - let Carlton run over the top of us in a final on his watch

2014 - kicked against the wind against Port

2015 - 9 disposals against north

For a so called elite player he sure does keep playing terribly when it actually matters.

Something is very wrong with this picture

[WA Tiger]

I will tell you after round 1..

[Diocletian]

I will tell you after we win a final.

fixed.

[(•))(©™]

None because they lack in comparative consistency to the opposition "Elitists"

[YellowandBlackBlood]

Cotchin:-

2013 - let Carlton run over the top of us in a final on his watch

2014 - kicked against the wind against Port

2015 - 9 disposals against north

For a so called elite player he sure does keep playing terribly when it actually matters.

Something is very wrong with this picture

You are correct except you are harsh about 2013. He was one of the best on ground in that game over the four quarters.

[Chuck17]

Cotchin:-

2013 - let Carlton run over the top of us in a final on his watch

2014 - kicked against the wind against Port

2015 - 9 disposals against north

For a so called elite player he sure does keep playing terribly when it actually matters.

Something is very wrong with this picture

You are correct except you are harsh about 2013. He was one of the best on ground in that game over the four quarters.

My recollection of 2013 is similar to yours, but just in case wine has dulled the years I went for the stats

http://www.richmondfc.com.au/season/statistics

Player          Kicks  Handballs   Disposals   Marks   Hit-outs   Frees For   Frees Agst   Tackles   Goals   
 Trent Cotchin   22      4      26      4      0   0   1      2              4      2

But maybe the fact that his mere presence didnt inspire the 10 or so spuds on the ground to lift can be counted against him   

[Diocletian]

Only three players stood up when the chips were down in the 2013 EF - Cotchin, Maric & Vlastuin. Fact.

[Stalin]

Yeah chimps the problem you morons

[WilliamPowell]

Only three players stood up when the chips were down in the 2013 EF - Cotchin, Maric & Vlastuin. Fact.

Agree

[MintOnLamb]

Only three players stood up when the chips were down in the 2013 EF - Cotchin, Maric & Vlastuin. Fact.

What about Miles?

[Yeahright]

Only three players stood up when the chips were down in the 2013 EF - Cotchin, Maric & Vlastuin. Fact.

What about Miles?

We didn't even have Miles then

[Chuck17]

Only three players stood up when the chips were down in the 2013 EF - Cotchin, Maric & Vlastuin. Fact.

What about Miles?

We didn't even have Miles then

Was he on the list before the rookie list?

Why wasn't he promoted to the rookie list that year?

[MintOnLamb]

Only three players stood up when the chips were down in the 2013 EF - Cotchin, Maric & Vlastuin. Fact.

What about Miles?

We didn't even have Miles then

My bad, i thought it was 2015 elim final