Who is your club's most important player? ..... (H-Sun)

[1980 I Was There]

Rance and Jack for mine.
I'd go as far as to say we are not a top 8 side without either of them in our side for the year.
We just have no cover for either of them.

Yeah agree totally.

But the real question is...
Do we have a player that can single handedly turn a game in our favour, such as wayne carey was able to do.
Hawthorn has one - mitchell.
Freo has one as well - Fyfe.

The closest we have to someone of that caliber is Lids, and no, Cotchin can't do that.

[Jonesracing82]

everyone says Rance/Maric/Lids are players we can't afford to be without, add Miles to that list, our Clearance results are significantly better when he is in the middle.

Was arguably Maric up until two years ago....now...

Rance

daylight


Reiwoldt


more daylight


Cotchin

Miles

Deledio



Townsend might be among that group by the end of this year....

I love Miles as much as anyone.

But is he really more important than Martin ?

different players, Dusty helps as he's great up fwd whereas Miles is a Clearance machine