Carlton vs Richmond

[Simonator]

Have they gone past us in their 1st year of rebuilding ? Is their list better than ours ? Are their coaches and list managers better than ours ? They've managed to offload Hampson grigg and yarren just to us let alone other clubs. Would we even beat Brisbane ? We have a great core group of players - Cotchin, Martin, Deledio, Rance, Jack, then Edwards, miles, grimes, vlastuin. Some promising youth, Rioli, Lennon, c Ellis, menadue. What's wrong with the club? Does it come down to culture ? Not enough players want to get their hands dirty. These are questions I've been asking the last few years. Time for a turnover of the coaching and list management positions.

[Stalin]

Carlton are ahead

Simply cause Bolton has some idea. Doesn't favor his spud mates

[mat073]

I believe Dimma has run his race .

Even when we win , we play an unwatchable, unexciting,  boring brand of football. We have won our last four games against the Blues - All of them not worthy of a second viewing.

If he was "replaced" with the right man....there is no doubt we could see a Carlton-esque resurgence.
I think it would reinvigorate our star players and is just what they need. We are just stagnating at the moment.
What an awesome victory Carlton had against Geelong recently where they lost two key players early in the match . So unrichmond like. We would turn to water.

How good would it be to have a coach like Beveridge who's not afraid to dump high profile players back to the VFL until their form demands selection.

[Raoul Duke]

They had a coach that was losing games, they kicked him to the curb and grabbed another,they now have what looks to be a good coach in the making.
Why do we have to give coaches 7 years to win a final?

Surely that is a well below standard for an AFL coach.

[Diocletian]

Because stability....

[Tigeritis™©®]

Have they gone past us in their 1st year of rebuilding ? Is their list better than ours ? Are their coaches and list managers better than ours ? They've managed to offload Hampson grigg and yarren just to us let alone other clubs. Would we even beat Brisbane ? We have a great core group of players - Cotchin, Martin, Deledio, Rance, Jack, then Edwards, miles, grimes, vlastuin. Some promising youth, Rioli, Lennon, c Ellis, menadue. What's wrong with the club? Does it come down to culture ? Not enough players want to get their hands dirty. These are questions I've been asking the last few years. Time for a turnover of the coaching and list management positions.

Tigeritis™

The whole club is infected and has been for a long long time. The poo is ingrained in its walls and all the wallpapering or painting will never fully rid the stench of mediocrity that pervades the halls of punt road. Eventually the smell of poo returns with a vegence like we are seeing now.

We need a coach with high grade medical disinfectant. One that's not scared to clean the joint from top to bottom and won't stop until the disease is finally gone.

[Jonesracing82]

Carlton are not as young a list as ppl think & it will still be a fair turnover of players at season's end, possibly the next 2 seasons

[TigerMonk]

No we are a better side than Carlton. Our club is simply riddled with injury. Confidence is down & some players need to be dropped while others need to be played & given time to adjust to AFL level. Not this come into the side & spend long periods on the bench. They need quality game time to find themselves, Confidence & adjust to higher level. Geez some of them would most likely breakout at the faster pace. Lennon would be in my side everyday as would Short. Astbury would be traded. His a average VFL player. 

[Stalin]

Carlton are not as young a list as ppl think & it will still be a fair turnover of players at season's end, possibly the next 2 seasons

Correct

But yet have more decent mature players than us IMHO

Richmond list drops away fast after rance and the other big four

[Yeahright]

 

[yellowandback]

3 months into a 3 year contract