Was stiff to get the axe at Carlton, especially when you look at what Malthouse dished up.
Been at Hawks during current success era. Has done more than Hardwick ever has, won a final. Has experience and can genuinely coach.
Anyone thinking Hardwick is the answer is simply dillusional. Contract or not for the sake of the entire club get someone fresh in there. Clean out the protected species, get ruthless at trade table and build a proper list with no favours instead of trying the same rubbish year in year out.
If not Rattan, entice Goodwin over as Roos may continue or give Stuart Dew a call. Nothing will change under Dimma, absolute fresh start is what is needed.
