Should we have taken Dunkley at pick 19 instead of trading it for Yarrran?

[🏅Dooks]

Kid is a machine. Yarran is a living douche.

Discuss.

[YellowandBlackBlood]

Sorry Dooks. Poor thread.
We traded pick 31 and this year's second rounder for pick 19 only so we could give Carlton what they wanted to get Yarran.
We never would have done so if we weren't after Yarran.

FACT.

[🏅Dooks]

Sorry Dooks. Poor thread.
We traded pick 31 and this year's second rounder for pick 19 only so we could give Carlton what they wanted to get Yarran.
We never would have done so if we weren't after Yarran.

FACT.

And we could have gone to all that trouble to draft a guy who was training with us at the time and who is now carving it up.

Pointless to you and thats inherently telling.

[YellowandBlackBlood]

Sorry Dooks. Poor thread.
We traded pick 31 and this year's second rounder for pick 19 only so we could give Carlton what they wanted to get Yarran.
We never would have done so if we weren't after Yarran.

FACT.

And we could have gone to all that trouble to draft a guy who was training with us at the time and who is now carving it up.

Missed 2 sitters right in front of goal tonight. Kicking was the weakness in his game. If he did that at the tigers he would immediately become chief whipping boy for some on these boards.

[big tone]

Sorry Dooks. Poor thread.
We traded pick 31 and this year's second rounder for pick 19 only so we could give Carlton what they wanted to get Yarran.
We never would have done so if we weren't after Yarran.

FACT.

And we could have gone to all that trouble to draft a guy who was training with us at the time and who is now carving it up.

Missed 2 sitters right in front of goal tonight. Kicking was the weakness in his game. If he did that at the tigers he would immediately become chief whipping boy for some on these boards.

He has shown a fair bit in his first year. Will be a pretty good player long term IMO.

[peggles]

dunkley's biggest achievement all year is how he stole the rising star nomination from oleg markov...

otherwise nothing special

[Diocletian]

Shyte kick and would look even worse at Richmond under Halfstep's crappy gameplan with no-one shepherding or running forward of the ball.....