It's a pretty sad state of affairs when we are judging who is the most poo out of those two. The only people that don't see it are the club.
One has made a career out of simply getting his hand to the footy first in a ruck contest regardless of where it goes, and not contributing in any other way, and the other isn't tall enough or good enough to player on KPF and is as slow as a wet week with the turning circle of the Queen Mary which makes it impossible to play on decent small or medium size forwards who also doesn't contribute much when we have the footy.
Now who is the most poo?
Add those 2 signings to the Maric, Grigg, Astbury and Houli signings and that pretty much sums up where we are as a club.
But even worse for me is giving away pick 6 for a slight upgrade on our very own A. Miles who I think has huge restrictions. Our list of decent kids is pretty slim at the minute and I cannot see the next Dusty/Rance/Cotch/Jack standard kid amongst them. Give away pick 6 is a massive mistake IMO, only time will tell how much but I'm tipping it will be significant. Just my opinion.