List changes going into the 2018 preseason

[1885]

I'm not sure chol needs to be delisted

 

[Andyy]

I've heard Chol is nowhere near it, and from the handful of quarters I've seen of the magoos before AFL games I would say there's not much to excite me.

Doesn't look like he knows what he's doing/where to run, and lacks effort. Very athletic of course but otherwise not much else to interest me.

[Dougeytherichmondfan]

I've heard Chol is nowhere near it, and from the handful of quarters I've seen of the magoos before AFL games I would say there's not much to excite me.

Doesn't look like he knows what he's doing/where to run, and lacks effort. Very athletic of course but otherwise not much else to interest me.

Thats the thing that concerns me about him. Its the stuff you cant really teach that hes very deficient in.

[big tone]

I'm not sure chol needs to be delisted

 

Chol is good

We rest our case

[Jackstar is back!!!]

I've heard Chol is nowhere near it, and from the handful of quarters I've seen of the magoos before AFL games I would say there's not much to excite me.

Doesn't look like he knows what he's doing/where to run, and lacks effort. Very athletic of course but otherwise not much else to interest me.

He is a long way from it
One player who can't seem to step up

[Chuck17]

I'm not sure chol needs to be delisted

 

Chol is good

We rest our case

Geez your attempt at humour is worse than mine, give it up for stuffs sake and go back to being the cranky old demented fan

[1885]

I've heard Chol is nowhere near it, and from the handful of quarters I've seen of the magoos before AFL games I would say there's not much to excite me.

Doesn't look like he knows what he's doing/where to run, and lacks effort. Very athletic of course but otherwise not much else to interest me.

Thats the thing that concerns me about him. Its the stuff you cant really teach that hes very deficient in.

He will get better at it the more games he plays.

Chol has taken like 10 huge marks in defence the last 3 weeks. Had a good game in the forward line yesterday. Nice marks. Goals. Assists. Lots of key contributions too

With our lack of rucks and tall fwds/backs it be pretty dumb to remove him from the list.

I'm not sure chol needs to be delisted

 

Chol is good

We rest our case

It's obvious to 90%+ of humanity rioli is a very good footballer. If you cannot see that it's tough titties.

[¾ T!geɹ]

FFS let him play at least 2 senior games before he is wiped of the face of the Tiger planet.
Looks to have talent (stuff me I hope he has) and we won't fully know until he plays a bit more.
Just like Townsend, first five years, kicked 4 goals and everybody seemed to go off him pretty quick (including me), then this year kicks 13 (so far).

I see the talent, just needs more senior match toughening up and learning, well that's just my opinion anyway, good luck Chol  .

[big tone]

I've heard Chol is nowhere near it, and from the handful of quarters I've seen of the magoos before AFL games I would say there's not much to excite me.

Doesn't look like he knows what he's doing/where to run, and lacks effort. Very athletic of course but otherwise not much else to interest me.

Thats the thing that concerns me about him. Its the stuff you cant really teach that hes very deficient in.

He will get better at it the more games he plays.

Chol has taken like 10 huge marks in defence the last 3 weeks. Had a good game in the forward line yesterday. Nice marks. Goals. Assists. Lots of key contributions too

With our lack of rucks and tall fwds/backs it be pretty dumb to remove him from the list.

I'm not sure chol needs to be delisted

 

Chol is good

We rest our case

It's obvious to 90%+ of humanity rioli is a very good footballer. If you cannot see that it's tough titties.

Rioli has done truck all yet to be classed a good footballer. He has talent but if you are honest with yourself he is just a kid that puts on good pressure. He isn't even a very good tackler yet.
He will be given every opportunity to become a good footballer but so was Andy Krakouer.

It's all good though we are in a prelim final. Let's hope he gets a kick this week. 

[Loui Tufga]

Chol is #1 for contested marks in the VFL this season.
For a guy who can't play that's not a bad stat to have under your belt

[Chuck17]

I've heard Chol is nowhere near it, and from the handful of quarters I've seen of the magoos before AFL games I would say there's not much to excite me.

Doesn't look like he knows what he's doing/where to run, and lacks effort. Very athletic of course but otherwise not much else to interest me.

Thats the thing that concerns me about him. Its the stuff you cant really teach that hes very deficient in.

He will get better at it the more games he plays.

Chol has taken like 10 huge marks in defence the last 3 weeks. Had a good game in the forward line yesterday. Nice marks. Goals. Assists. Lots of key contributions too

With our lack of rucks and tall fwds/backs it be pretty dumb to remove him from the list.

I'm not sure chol needs to be delisted

 

Chol is good

We rest our case

It's obvious to 90%+ of humanity rioli is a very good footballer. If you cannot see that it's tough titties.

Rioli has done truck all yet to be classed a good footballer. He has talent but if you are honest with yourself he is just a kid that puts on good pressure. He isn't even a very good tackler yet.
He will be given every opportunity to become a good footballer but so was Andy Krakouer.

It's all good though we are in a prelim final. Let's hope he gets a kick this week. 

He did enough to be selected as in the under 22 side of the year which was acknowledged by everyone but you

[Dougeytherichmondfan]

Chol is #1 for contested marks in the VFL this season.
For a guy who can't play that's not a bad stat to have under your belt

People here arn't questioning his ability as much as they are his deficiencies vs his strengths. He goes missing a lot.

Vickery was #2 in the comp behind Cloke at the peak of his powers in 2012 for contested marks (not 100% sure on that but remember it being brandied around on SEN).

Chol played v well yesterday. 

[big tone]

I've heard Chol is nowhere near it, and from the handful of quarters I've seen of the magoos before AFL games I would say there's not much to excite me.

Doesn't look like he knows what he's doing/where to run, and lacks effort. Very athletic of course but otherwise not much else to interest me.

Thats the thing that concerns me about him. Its the stuff you cant really teach that hes very deficient in.

He will get better at it the more games he plays.

Chol has taken like 10 huge marks in defence the last 3 weeks. Had a good game in the forward line yesterday. Nice marks. Goals. Assists. Lots of key contributions too

With our lack of rucks and tall fwds/backs it be pretty dumb to remove him from the list.

I'm not sure chol needs to be delisted

 

Chol is good

We rest our case

It's obvious to 90%+ of humanity rioli is a very good footballer. If you cannot see that it's tough titties.

Rioli has done truck all yet to be classed a good footballer. He has talent but if you are honest with yourself he is just a kid that puts on good pressure. He isn't even a very good tackler yet.
He will be given every opportunity to become a good footballer but so was Andy Krakouer.

It's all good though we are in a prelim final. Let's hope he gets a kick this week. 

He did enough to be selected as in the under 22 side of the year which was acknowledged by everyone but you

That side was voted on by "the fans"
Give me a spell, if you are voting on those sort of things you need to get a life.
How many times did you vote Chuck17??

[Chuck17]

I've heard Chol is nowhere near it, and from the handful of quarters I've seen of the magoos before AFL games I would say there's not much to excite me.

Doesn't look like he knows what he's doing/where to run, and lacks effort. Very athletic of course but otherwise not much else to interest me.

Thats the thing that concerns me about him. Its the stuff you cant really teach that hes very deficient in.

He will get better at it the more games he plays.

Chol has taken like 10 huge marks in defence the last 3 weeks. Had a good game in the forward line yesterday. Nice marks. Goals. Assists. Lots of key contributions too

With our lack of rucks and tall fwds/backs it be pretty dumb to remove him from the list.

I'm not sure chol needs to be delisted

 

Chol is good

We rest our case

It's obvious to 90%+ of humanity rioli is a very good footballer. If you cannot see that it's tough titties.

Rioli has done truck all yet to be classed a good footballer. He has talent but if you are honest with yourself he is just a kid that puts on good pressure. He isn't even a very good tackler yet.
He will be given every opportunity to become a good footballer but so was Andy Krakouer.

It's all good though we are in a prelim final. Let's hope he gets a kick this week. 

He did enough to be selected as in the under 22 side of the year which was acknowledged by everyone but you

That side was voted on by "the fans"

So?

[Owl]

I stick by my Chol support, talls can take longer to kick on, he has a lot of good about him.  Callum Moore looks the goods too