Jon Ralph’s player ratings of all 44 players in the Richmond v Adelaide clashJON RALPH,
Herald Sun
28 September 2017IT looms as an intriguing battle between the high-scoring Crows and frenetic pressure of the Tigers.
JON RALPH ranks every player based on their importance to the outcome.
1. Dustin Martin (Richmond)The complete player.
Born for footy and born for September, he holds the fate of this game in his hand after an awesome year and two epic finals.
Last week he set up the opening goal, had 20 disposals, finished with three clutch goals and gave two off as well. 13 of those 20 disposals led to scores.
Incredible.
2. Alex Rance (Richmond)The game’s best defender has four All Australian nods and now is putting together the finals resume he needs to challenge Matthew Scarlett as this generation’s best full back.
Ranks second in intercept possessions but also a threat with ball in hand. And to think he might have walked away from footy.
3. Trent Cotchin (Richmond)His redefined his reputation with a phenomenal finals series, highlighted by frenzied assault on the ball and man.
The baby-faced assassin won a staggering 78 per cent of his possessions against Geelong in the contest, and is in white-hot form.
Nine tackles in both finals.
4. Rory Sloane (Adelaide)Identical stats to Cotchin this year but is shaded only by his inability to break the tag and a good-but-not-great 20 possessions in the prelim.
The boy from Upwey Tecoma is Adelaide’s fire-starter. He dominates, they win.
5. Eddie Betts (Adelaide)Betts has such profound talent he could rip this game from Richmond’s grasp in the space of five minutes.
54 goals for the year, third for assists and with a penchant for the sublime. What a player.
6. Matt Crouch (Adelaide)A faultless home-and-away season keeps getting better with an All Australian nod and two 31-possession finals.
Yet to be tagged this year but write him off at your peril as an accumulator who doesn’t hurt you. Freakishly good.
7. Tom Lynch (Adelaide)Fresh from two goals and 10 score involvements in the prelim, Richmond might have to tag the AFL’s best connector.
Not even viral meningitis can stop the ginger ninja, who ranks 2nd for disposals and No.1 for score involvements as a forward.
8. Rory Laird (Adelaide)Quick, agile, fearless, great skills, what a defender.
The best small defender in footy racks it up as an offensive weapon and cannot be allowed to run free if Richmond is to win.
Fresh off a brilliant preliminary final.
9. Brad Crouch (Adelaide)Hard as a cat’s head, with comparisons to Joel Selwood for toughness this week.
Like brother Matt superb in two finals (27 and 28 touches), finally living up to the massive hype. Will end up going past Matt.
10. Sam Jacobs (Adelaide)Rucks with aplomb then controls the game around the ground. His ruck dominance in Round 6 didn’t convert into scores, but will back himself to be a Tank-buster again.
11. Toby Nankervis (Richmond)So much more than a bash-and-crash ruckman, the boy from North Launceston huge in two finals so far.
Richmond can’t win if Sam Jacobs smacks him like in Round 6, so he is elevated to a lofty ranking here.
Jack Riewoldt has been quiet in the Tigers’ first two finals. Pic: Michael Klein
12. Jack Riewoldt (Richmond)Another Tiger to grow in front of our eyes, poor body language and indifferent second efforts now replaced by devotion to the cause.
Simply must bring the ball to ground, given Adelaide’s 21 intercept marks in Round 6 killed the Tigers.
13. Taylor Walker (Adelaide)The boy from Broken Hill might not be Wayne Carey with his aerial contests but the No.1 assists player in the comp will have to do as a stunning stat.
And he came up with the Crows deathstare...
14. David Astbury (Richmond)Huge role on Grand Final day. Should take Tex with Rance playing deeper, but colours lowered early v GWS after best year of his career.
Nearly left for Brisbane and now has the Grand Final as his defensive stage. Tigers can’t win if he doesn’t win aerial battles.
15. Dion Prestia (Richmond)They paid him big bucks for midfield numbers but we rank him this high because he is Richmond’s cooler, shutting down Josh Kelly last week.
Now must go to Sloane or Matt Crouch. Tigers can’t win if they both fire.
16. Jake Lever (Adelaide)
In likely his last game for Adelaide, can the AFL’s best intercept player control the skies like Brian Lake in his Norm Smith Medal winning performance?
Jacob Townsend likely to go to him in negating role.
17. Daniel Rioli (Richmond)Cousin Cyril set the MCG alight in his first Grand Final then won Normie in 2015.
Can he continue that family tradition like Cyril and Maurice before him? Elite pressure plus four prelim goals but likely opponent Luke Brown a jet.
18. Dylan Grimes (Richmond)Elevated in this list because of likely role on Betts, who he kept goalless despite avalanche in Round 6.
The deep-thinking hobby farmer and vigneron might have this game’s toughest match up.
19. Daniel Talia (Adelaide)Certain to get Jack Riewoldt, and needs only to push him under the ball and disrupt his aerial presence to play his role.
The AFL’s most miserly defender kept Hawkins to a single goal last week.
20. Charlie Cameron (Adelaide)Has to be in your Norm Smith contenders, capable of ripping this tame apart after five in the prelim. Not sure the Tigers have a match-up for him.
Charlie Cameron was everywhere against the Cats. Picture Sarah Reed
21. Kane Lambert (Richmond)The former Preston factory worker has had a career year, kicking the prelim’s first goal and averaging 21 possessions and five tackles.
What a great state-league success story.
22. Nick Vlastuin (Richmond)Richmond will try to free up elite interceptor Vlastuin, who mixes rugged aggression with solid marking. Can he help hold back the dam wall on Douglas or Otten?
23. Richard Douglas (Adelaide)Underestimate at your peril, with this dangerous half forward from Broadford bobbing up with 20 possessions and two qualifying final goals.
A Grand Final haul wouldn’t surprise.
24. Luke Brown (Adelaide)Puts his opponents to sleep every single time, not conceding multiple goals to an opponent since Round 8.
Sure to get Daniel Rioli, fresh off four goals. Can’t wait for this match-up to unfold.
25. Shane Edwards (Richmond)
An underrated year for Richmond’s energiser with two big finals.
Wins so much contested ball at half forward, second only to Dusty for score assists. Beloved inside the club.
26. Bachar Houli (Richmond)Richmond’s offensive weapon from half back, as well as an inspiration off the field. Under-rated in the air, creative on the ground.
Two excellent finals averaging 20 touches and 440 metres gained.
27. Kyle Hartigan (Adelaide)Kyle who? Actually, the bloke who stopped Patrick Dangerfield last week and the man who will get Dustin Martin forward.
Since coming back from a serious hammy, he torched Josh Kennedy, kept Jeremy Cameron to a goal and didn’t conceded a goal to Danger or Dan Menzel.
28. Rory Atkins (Adelaide)Just part of the Adelaide machine, a permanent winger averaging 22 touches and giving plenty of drive.
29. Dan Butler (Richmond)Far more than a pressure player, this lightning-fast surprise packet has kicked 29 goals for the year. Cashed in on pressure with late 2 prelim goals.
30. Josh Caddy (Richmond)A potential game-breaker who has 21 goals, buckets of hardness and a strong aerial presence.
31. Paul Seedsman (Adelaide)What a story, playing 4 games Round 19 and kicking five goals and adding yet more run to the Crows outfit. And the Pies didn’t want him ...
Josh Jenkins will be a threat on the ground and in the air. Picture: Getty Images
32. Josh Jenkins (Adelaide)Just how do we rate this bloke? He is the ultimate polarising player, labelled by some as the junk-time king but still huge for their structure with 45.21 for the year.
Just one disposal to quarter time last week yet the Crows were six goals up. But if he plays deep will get Alex Rance and need to keep him accountable.
33. Brandon Ellis (Richmond)Career-best year for the West Coburg product who has averaged 23 disposals and six intercept possessions after his place in the side was questioned in the pre-season.
34. Shaun Grigg (Richmond)The most unlikely Grand Final ruckman you have ever seen. Plus a hard-at-it mid who kicks goals (14) and can tag to boot.
Traded for Andrew Collins, a masterful trade for the Tigers.
35. Nathan Broad (Richmond)Hasn’t missed a game since Round 17 recall and has lost just four of 22 one-on-one contests, twice this year keeping Toby Greene goalless.
But what a role — shutting down either Tom Lynch or Eddie Betts. Adelaide will try to exploit this WAFL recruit.
Richmond's Nathan Broad is a quiet achiever. Pic: Michael Klein
36. David Mackay (Adelaide)This former Oakleigh Charger is key part of the midfield mix, fairly nondescript but so valuable. Won’t be winning Normie but won’t let Don Pyke down either.
37. Riley Knight (Adelaide)Adelaide don’t often tag but if they do he is the bloke who Pyke will call on.
Having gone to Adam Treloar and Joel Selwood already, he’s the guy to put out a midfield bushfire.
38. Jason Castagna (Richmond)Typifies the Richmond resurgence with relentless pressure and goal-a-game attacking prowess.
He has his tail up after 18 touches and a goal against GWS.
39. Hugh GreenwoodA season-low six disposals last week for Greenwood, who plays the least amount of game time in the AFL.
But the former Perth Wildcat pays his way with elite pressure skills.
40. Kamdyn McIntosh (Richmond)The Pinjarra kid has been solid rather than explosive with 26 possessions in two finals but is another hard-running Dimma role player.
41. Jake Kelly (Adelaide)How the hell did the Pies let this guy fall through the cracks?
The son of Craig might get Caddy or Townsend after keeping Dan Menzel goalless and Toby Greene to a goal. Another bargain-basement success story.
42. Andy Otten (Adelaide)The ultimate utility who has played forward defence and even ruck this year and holds his spot with McGovern’s hamstring.
Has kicked 20 goals in 18 games and plays his role in the triangle offence which has worked to such stunning effect.
43. Jack Graham (Richmond)A tackling fiend (eight a game) who after being taken at pick 53 plays midfield and half forward and could play in a flag in his fifth premiership.
44. Jacob Townsend (Richmond)The JJ Liston Medallist was looking for a job five weeks ago.
Now the former Giant has a remarkable 14 goals from 28 kicks and might got to Jake Lever to make a pest of himself in the air.
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/more-news/jon-ralph-ranks-every-adelaide-and-richmond-player-in-the-afl-grand-final/news-story/8c1882d5694c26cf81ade42f73ede08a