Tarrant 34 will retire
Riewoldt will retire
Cotchin will retire
Short is superfluous to needs and going by how much everyone rates him would get us a decent pick.
Colina has hardly got going.
Nyuon is not even a mention for a key spot with injuries.
Prestia would probably retire if he hasanother serious hammy or soft tissue injury
Ross is so meh trade wont get much though.
Soldo should have gone when he had the chance last year.
Mansell way behind others after how many seasons.
Dow needs a real big season
Graham is tradeable
Baker is tradeable
McIntosh servicable have been looking for an upgrade for years now.
Agree with most of that, although I do think guys like Graham and Baker are best 22 and imperative for culture/leadership reasons and thus wouldn't trade them myself (not likely to get much in a trade on performance value but I rate them higher than their own field performances alone).
Shorty, where do we play him? Rioli looks better off HBF, plays closer and maybe tougher too. Can Short play wing?
Colina sounds like he'll never get going.
Biggie I'm worried is still on our list and wasn't even in the conversation for a game vs Carlton but yet that new guy we picked up with a nothing pick was being thrown around.
Ross I see as a failure of the club. He should have been at least a B grade inside mid but we stuffed him by messing his position around so much and now we've traded in T&H which makes him properly redundant. He's not fast enough or damaging enough in any way to be a useful substitute either.
Soldo I suspect may never reach his serviceable 19-20 heights.
Mansell is a VFL player end of story. Like his mongrel but it is what it is.
Dow I suspect will be delisted. Sonsie ahead of him after his first 6 months on the list.
Macca I really like him and see him as a useful utility player.
