Brownlow 2023 thread

[lamington]

There were way too many dubious moments. Speaking of midfielders being gifted the Brownlow,  I feel for Jeremy cameron with his 1 vote in round 2. Also not to mention the other Brisbane game where Neale got 3 votes even though he barely touched it and Charlie cameron kicked 7

[Andyy]

Hahaha those cheats should never vote on a game again. stuffin losers the lot of em.

Jason Horne-Francis got three votes against Geelong from 13 disposals, one tackle and no goals. Four of those touches were ineffective, two were clangers and he was not among the nine players who polled coaches’ votes.

Laughable isn't it. And Taylor Adams R3 lol. 20 touches, 3 contested, no goals, about 1-2 tackles.

It's a joke.

Brownlow votes should include coach and maybe captain input.

While I get yours and Frankie's point, end of the day they got it right

Lachie Neale had another great year and us deserved winner

Added bonus Pies fans sooking that young Nick was robbed

He might've had a great year bur he was nowhere near the best or most damaging player in the comp. ....as someone pointed out last night ,the supposedly "not damaging enough" Taranto hit the scoreboard more this year than both of Neale's Brownlow years combined and certainly wasn't the best player in the comp this year either....joke of an award and  has been for years....even when Dusty won it in 2017 he was nearly knocked off by Dangerfield who couldn't hit the side of a barn all year....

Danger kicked 45 that year. Dusty was supreme though and less selfish

[georgies31]

Neal winning it says alot bang average player.

[Diocletian]

Hahaha those cheats should never vote on a game again. stuffin losers the lot of em.

Jason Horne-Francis got three votes against Geelong from 13 disposals, one tackle and no goals. Four of those touches were ineffective, two were clangers and he was not among the nine players who polled coaches’ votes.

Laughable isn't it. And Taylor Adams R3 lol. 20 touches, 3 contested, no goals, about 1-2 tackles.

It's a joke.

Brownlow votes should include coach and maybe captain input.

While I get yours and Frankie's point, end of the day they got it right

Lachie Neale had another great year and us deserved winner

Added bonus Pies fans sooking that young Nick was robbed

He might've had a great year bur he was nowhere near the best or most damaging player in the comp. ....as someone pointed out last night ,the supposedly "not damaging enough" Taranto hit the scoreboard more this year than both of Neale's Brownlow years combined and certainly wasn't the best player in the comp this year either....joke of an award and  has been for years....even when Dusty won it in 2017 he was nearly knocked off by Dangerfield who couldn't hit the side of a barn all year....

Danger kicked 45 that year. Dusty was supreme though and less selfish

Talking about his field kicking - no-one was even close to Dusty that year and he should've won in a canter, not by 3 votes in the last round from a bloke who played one less h&a game....

[Assange Tiger 😎]

Neal winning it says alot bang average player.

he's an absolute gun. I don't think he should have won this year but average player? Ffs

[georgies31]

Neal winning it says alot bang average player.

he's an absolute gun. I don't think he should have won this year but average player? Ffs

Gets cheap possessions with little influence and his big numbers get him the votes.

[Diocletian]

Neal winning it says alot bang average player.

he's an absolute gun. I don't think he should have won this year but average player? Ffs

Come off it AT - he's no BEllis....

[Willy]

Neal winning it says alot bang average player.

he's an absolute gun. I don't think he should have won this year but average player? Ffs

Gets cheap possessions with little influence and his big numbers get him the votes.

Cmon mate. He dominated us in the elim final last year.

He didn’t deserve to win the Chaz but he’s objectively a gun.