Author Topic: AFL discuss 17-6 conference fixture / Interstate clubs want best of 3 GFs (HSun)  (Read 2014 times)

Offline one-eyed

  • Administrator
  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 98225
    • One-Eyed Richmond
17-6 fixture redraw concept under consideration following AFL conference with club CEO’s

Jay Clark
HeraldSun
July 20, 2023


Every side could play each other once before the ladder is divided into three groups for the last six rounds as part of a future fixture revamp being considered by the AFL and club chief executives.

Senior figures gathered for a two-day conference to discuss the key issues facing the game including increasing the soft cap, a mid-season trade period, Tasmania’s new team, AFLW and ways to revamp the fixture.

It included a left-field idea to move to a best-of-three grand final series which has support from interstate clubs, but the longshot proposal would be difficult to implement.

Officials present at the meeting on Wednesday said the 30-minute discussion on the fixture was designed to stimulate ideas to enhance and add value and fairness to the competition.

There were mixed views on the wildcard concept which would see the seventh-placed side take on 10th-placed team and eighth challenge ninth to secure a finals berth.

But sources on Wednesday said there was potentially stronger support for an overhaul of the fixture to divide the ladder into three pools of six after each club had played each other once.

It means at round 18 the fixture would be redrawn so teams in the top-six would play each other, the middle-six teams would be grouped together, and the bottom-six would all lock horns.

But sources were at pains to say the concepts were only discussed broadly and that any changes to the AFL fixture could be three years away following significant input and development.

The fixture redraw has significant benefits as it would help create more even competition among the teams who are slated to play the other sides from the same bracket.

It would essentially replace the wildcard weekend concept and see teams in the top-six play for top-six spots and the middle-six vie for seventh and eighth-place.

Sources on Wednesday said it created a more equitable scenario across the fixture with heavy emphasis placed on the outcome of every team playing each other once.

There are concerns there current 24-round fixture is too heavily compromised by the teams each sides are drawn to play twice, including cellar-dwellers North Melbourne and West Coast.

However, the 17-6 redesign may also have to include a rivalry round where the local derbies and major rivalries are played for a second time, including the West Australian ‘Derby’ and South Australian ‘Showdown’.

The league would potentially incorporate Gather Round as part of the first 17-match block.

https://www.codesports.com.au/afl/176-fixture-redraw-concept-under-consideration-following-afl-conference-with-club-ceos/news-story/cf469fc9615a0682f9966c23f41b92fa

Offline Damo

  • RFC Hall of Fame
  • *****
  • Posts: 4494
  • Member of famed “Gang Of Four”. Ground the airbus!
Lets pretend this 17-6 concept was implemented and took this years ladder as an example.

It's so flawed I can't even begin ..

Gold Coast WOULD play finals footy from 13th, no doubt.
St Kilda WOULD miss finals no doubt

You would have teams willing to lose in round 17 so they get thrown into the bottom or mid pool depending on ladder position.

eg, would GWS be better off losing to Adelaide be enough % and being 13th on the ladder (bottom tier), or winning and being in the middle tier? would Geelong have been better of losing and locking in middle tier instead of top tier? etc etc

Then there is the travel factor. The bottom 6 this year has 4 interstate teams, nightmare for the Victorian teams needing to travel an extra couple of times in the year. Not to mention logistics.

Anyway, good luck AFL. Keep stuffing it up like you always do.